Glomerular matrix metalloproteinases and their regulators in the pathogenesis of lupus nephritis
© BioMed Central Ltd 2008
Published: 1 December 2008
Skip to main content
© BioMed Central Ltd 2008
Published: 1 December 2008
Lupus nephritis is a major contributor to morbidity and mortality in systemic lupus erythematosus, but little is known about the pathogenic processes that underlie the progressive decay in renal function. A common finding in lupus nephritis is thickening of glomerular basement membranes associated with immune complex deposition. It has been speculated that alterations in the synthesis or degradation of membrane components might contribute to such changes, and thereby to initiation and progression of nephritis through facilitation of immune complex deposition. Matrix metalloproteinases (MMPs) are enzymes that are intimately involved in the turnover of major glomerular basement membrane constituents, including collagen IV and laminins. Alterations in the expression and activity of MMPs have been described in a number of renal diseases, suggesting their relevance to the pathogenesis of various glomerulopathies. The same is true for their natural inhibitors, the tissue inhibitor of metalloproteinase family. Recent data from our group have identified an increase in proteolytic activity within the glomerulus coinciding with the development of proteinuria in the mouse model of systemic lupus erythematosus. (NXB × NZW)F1 Here we review current understanding of MMP/tissue inhibitor of metalloproteinase function within the kidney, and discuss their possible involvement in the development and progression of lupus nephritis.
Systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) is a complex auto-immune disease that is characterized by chronic inflammatory processes involving autoimmunity against multiple organ-specific and ubiquitous self-antigens. One commonly affected organ is the kidney, with the appearance of lupus nephritis ranging in severity from mild proteinuria to overt nephrotic syndrome progressing to end-stage renal disease. Although the molecular mechanisms that underlie the pathogenesis of nephritis remain largely obscure, disturbances in apoptotic signalling, phagocytosis and complement function have all been proposed as factors involved in initiation of auto-immunity and progression of the disease [1, 2].
Expansion and/or disruption of the intraglomerular extra-cellular matrix is a well recognized phenomenon occurring during the development of lupus nephritis that may have an impact on renal immune complex deposition. Little is known, however, about the structure and composition of the expanded regions or the mediators of such changes. Increased or altered synthesis of extracellular matrix (ECM) constituents and/or their decreased breakdown could potentially play a role, although the contribution made by each of these factors remains unknown.
Another common finding in lupus nephropathy is the appearance of electron dense structures (EDSs) within mesangium or intimately linked to the glomerular capillary membranes, as seen on electron micrographs. These structures contain immune complexes with autoantibodies and chromatin fragments [3, 4], and a recent study  has demonstrated a considerable affinity of nucleosomes toward the major matrix constituents laminin and collagen IV. It is therefore possible that alterations in the composition of the glomerular ECM may affect its interaction with immune complexes, thus facilitating their deposition and subsequent damage to glomerular structures. Indeed, qualitative as well as quantitative alterations in the makeup of the extracellular membranes of the glomerulus in lupus nephritis have already been described [6, 7]. Candidate mediators of such changes include enzymes and signalling substances involved in maintaining the delicate balance between synthesis and breakdown of the proteins and proteoglycans that make up the ECM.
Although some studies have provided evidence of increased levels of expression of collagens and laminins, less is known about the kinetics of breakdown of these proteins. Turnover of ECM proteins is largely achieved through the action of matrix metalloproteinases (MMPs), which represent a major class of matrix-degrading proteinases. Thus, from its effect on capillary membranes and mesangial matrix composition, a putative role emerges for altered glomerular MMP activity in lupus nephritis. Exploring this possibility, however, is complicated by the many levels of regulation of proteinase activity. Also, there is an emerging appreciation of considerable functional divergence of both MMPs and their regulators, particularly the tissue inhibitors of metalloproteinase (TIMPs).
In this review we outline some of the current knowledge on MMP expression and regulation within the kidney in lupus nephritis, including clues gained from studies in other renal inflammatory diseases.
MMPs are a group of Zn2+-dependent proteins that are found in the extracellular milieu of various tissues. Based on sequence homology and substrate specificities, the MMPs can be classified into several subgroups including collagenases, gelatinases, stromelysins, matrilysins and the membrane-type metalloproteinases. There is considerable overlap in substrate specificities, and the MMPs appear to be involved in degradation of abundant ECM components, including laminins, collagens and fibronectin, but also in the release and turnover of cytokines and cell surface receptors of adjacent cells .
The gelatinases cleave a number of substrates, including native forms of collagens I, IV, V, VII, X and XI, elastin, laminin, fibronectin, myelin and the core protein of proteoglycans. (A comprehensive list of substrates for the various MMPs can be found in the Overall Lab Web Site .) Another metalloproteinase that is notable for its affinity for collagen IV is MMP-7 (matrilysin 1) . Produced in both the tubular and glomerular compartment, it was recently described to be involved in several types of renal diseases with glomerular involvement, including diabetic nephropathy and X-linked Alport syndrome [11, 12]. In addition to collagen IV, MMP-7 is a major factor in the turnover of tenascin (an oligomeric glyco-protein that is important for the functioning of the glomerular filtration barrier)  and other basement membrane components, such as laminin, entactin and proteoglycans, as well as in activation of several proinflammatory mediators, including MMP-2 and MMP-9 [14, 15]. The relevance of MMP-7 in SLE has not yet been evaluated, but it remains an interesting candidate mediator of changes in membrane composition in lupus nephritis.
MMP-2 is constitutively expressed in mesangial cells, with some contribution made by the podocytes and little or no expression in glomerular endothelial cells [16, 17]. The expression is dramatically increased in various glomerulopathies, probably as a result of proinflammatory signalling [18, 19]. MMP-9 is present at negligible levels in normal kidney glomeruli, but it is induced during the course of several renal inflammatory diseases, with mesangial cells and infiltrating neutrophils being the main sources . Recent data from our laboratory  indicate an increase in glomerular proteolytic activity at around the onset of proteinuria in a model of lupus nephritis in (NZB × NZW)F1 mice, with MMP-9 being a major contributor.
The many roles of MMPs in vivo require a complex network of modulation of enzymatic activity. Key regulators are the TIMPs, of which four subtypes are currently known. The TIMPs form 1:1 complexes with metalloproteinases, with only modest variations in affinity toward the different MMPs . The central role played by TIMPs in the regulation of MMP activity has led to the hypothesis that shifts in the balance between these two families of proteins could distort the kinetics of membrane turnover and cause pathological changes in membrane composition [23, 24].
When considering the relevance of TIMP expression in renal disease, it is important to note that several members of the TIMP family appear to have functions of pathophysiological significance that is not directly related to ECM homeostasis/MMP regulation. One such facet is the apparent involvement in both pro-apoptotic and anti-apoptotic signalling pathways [25–27]. Various disturbances in apoptosis and the clearance of dead cells have been proposed to form a source of autoreactivity in SLE, which raises the possibility that TIMPs are involved in regulating apoptotic cell death in the context of autoimmune disorders.
A full account of the field of TIMP biology is beyond the scope of this review, and we limit the discussion to apoptosis-related aspects of their functioning. Whereas the molecular basis for TIMP-mediated signalling is still poorly understood, an emerging view is that they interact extensively with cell surface proteins, thus imposing modulation of various downstream signalling pathways.
Cell culture studies have reported anti-apoptotic effects of TIMP-1, some of which rely on its MMP-inhibitory function, whereas others appear independent of interaction with MMPs [28–30]. A recent in vitro study conducted in HeLa cervical cancer cells identified promyelocytic leukaemia zinc finger protein (PLZF) – a well known transcriptional repressor – to be a potential binding partner for TIMP-1 . It was shown that the addition/over-expression of TIMP-1 reduced the percentage of apoptotic cells in this system in a PLZF-dependant manner. PLZF is expressed in myeloid cells, ovaries and, at low level, in kidney and lung tissues. The interaction between TIMP-1 and PLZF is reported to occur by direct interaction between the two proteins within the nucleus .
The concept of TIMP-1 translocating into the nucleus remains controversial [32, 33], and the functions of TIMP in this location in vivo remain to be identified. However, as discussed below, several recent studies have reported that MMPs are present within the nucleus , offering new perspectives on the biological roles played MMPs and possibly TIMPs as well. For TIMP-2 and TIMP-4, reports have been partly contradictory, with both pro-apoptotic and anti-apoptotic effects being described, and further studies are awaited to characterize their putative roles in apoptosis and cell viability. TIMP-3 appears to have pro-apoptotic properties, attributed to the inhibition of both the MMP and ADAM (a disintegrin and metalloproteinase) families of matrix metalloproteinases . One possible basis for these functions is the fact that certain ADAMs and MMPs are involved in the shedding of a number of cell surface receptors that are involved in pro-apoptotic and anti-apoptotic signalling pathways, including tumour necrosis factor receptors  and Fas receptor . Studies conducted in tumor cells have shown that over-expression of TIMP-3 causes stimulation of Fas/Fas ligand signalling  and results in increased apoptotic activity. Involvement of TIMPs in the regulation of death pathways including Fas/Fas ligand is an interesting finding, because alterations in Fas function appear to be relevant to autoantibody production and possibly to the development of nephritis .
Studies of tissue MMPs are complicated by the complexity of the regulatory network that governs their activity in vivo. A MMP-9 knockout mouse exhibited no or modest structural/functional abnormalities, both on a healthy background and in a model of Alport syndrome , which could be explained by redundancy of the system based on observations of compensatory upregulation of other MMPs, including MMP-2 . Caution is therefore required when interpreting studies that are limited to one or a few MMPs, and such findings also suggest that therapeutic utilization of broad-spectrum inhibitors of MMP activity might be a more desirable strategy than more targeted ones, at least in some settings.
Increased gene expression and protein levels of the MMPs are often found to be accompanied by increases in the levels of one or more of the TIMPs. It is therefore not obvious what can be the net result of these opposing stimuli in terms of ECM turnover. In situ zymography is a technique that allows localization of active proteinases (including MMPs) within the tissues, providing valuable information about the net result of MMP regulation. It is done by incubating tissue sections with a fluorescence-marked substrate, which gives a direct visual impression of local proteinase activity .
Data on metalloproteinase activity in lupus nephritis is limited to few reports of altered gene expression patterns in murine and human kidneys [19, 20, 43]. There have also been reports of increased circulating levels of several MMPs, notably MMP-9, in sera from lupus patients [44–47]. Of note, circulating MMP-9 levels have been found to be inversely correlated to levels of antibodies against double-stranded DNA, which is commonly used as a marker of SLE disease activity . No such correlations were observed for MMP-2 or MMP-3 [44, 48, 49]. The source(s) of serum MMPs probably includes circulating leucocytes, especially neutrophils and monocytes, whereas the contribution from the tissues is uncertain. Serum MMP measurements thus may be of limited value in elucidating their potential roles in end organ disease, and the organ-focused studies suggest different roles for the MMPs within the various tissue spaces. Nevertheless, increased circulating levels of MMP-9 have been described in SLE patients with evidence of neuropsychiatric manifestations . Also, a recent study  identified increased MMP-9 activity in cerebrospinal fluid from SLE patients, with significantly higher levels in patients with evidence of central nervous system involvement. There are reports indicating a central role for MMPs in increasing permeability of the blood-brain barrier in inflammatory settings , which could be of relevance in SLE.
Owing to overlapping morphological and clinical presentations of various kinds of inflammatory diseases of the glomerulus, the results of studies of the involvement of MMP activity in other renal pathologies should provide valuable guidance in elucidating the role of these enzymes in lupus nephritis.
Although one might speculate that increased MMP activity is not detrimental, but rather represents a favourable compensatory response to aberrant matrix synthesis, this appears unlikely considering the favourable outcome of MMP inhibition/knockout strategies in other glomerulopathies . Much of the data currently available come from work in models of antibody-induced nephropathies, such as anti-Thy 1.1 nephritis  and passive Heymann's nephritis , and from non-immune models such as ischemia/reperfusion renal scarring induced by ureteral ligation [56, 57], all of which trigger inflammatory responses  that lead to progressive tubulointerstitial fibrosis and glomerulosclerosis. A common theme in these studies is a marked increase in either one or both of the gelatinases (MMP-2 or MMP-9) [18, 19, 59, 60]. Often an increase in TIMP-1 is observed within the glomeruli, which (as mentioned above) complicates the interpretation of results. The finding that gelatinase levels are increased in a situation of ECM accumulation might appear paradoxical, because this would be expected to increase collagen breakdown. A simple explanation is that the increased expression is a compensatory response to an increase in the synthesis of matrix components. Although there are reports indicating that collagen IV increases early in glomerulonephritis , others have found collagen IV expression to appear relatively stable .
Preliminary data from our laboratory support the latter in the case of (NZB × NZW)F1 and MRL/lpr lupus-prone mice (Tveita A, unpublished data). As stated above, the relative contribution of increased synthesis and decreased degradation of collagen IV to ECM accumulation remains undetermined. Studies showing that MMP inhibition attenuates ECM accumulation in rat allograft nephropathy , anti-Thy 1.1 nephritis  and other experimental inflammatory renal diseases would suggest that matrix degradation plays at least some role in this process. As discussed below, there are also indications that the MMPs confer proliferative stimuli upon mesangial cells, providing another factor that might explain an increase in MMP activity in the face of nephritis and matrix proliferation .
The mesangium appears to play a central role in the development of glomerulonephritis. The contribution made by mesangial cells to inflammatory diseases of the kidneys is thought to be twofold: increased proliferation and proinflammatory response; and synthesis of matrix components, causing ECM accumulation. Mesangial cell culture experiments have implicated MMP-2 as a possible regulator of both of the above factors. Indeed, inhibition by both pharmacological and ribozyme-mediated approaches have shown reduction in MMP-2 activity to be associated with transformation of actively proliferating mesangial cells to a state of quiescence by induction of G0/G1 cell cycle arrest .
Treatment of cultured rat mesangial cell with a relatively unspecific MMP inhibitor caused a decrease in proliferative activity of up to 75% and evidence of decreased levels of activation . In addition, MMP inhibitor experiments also demonstrated a significant increase in the number of apoptotic cells both in anti-Thy 1.1 nephritis and in cultured mesangial cells, probably mediated through a caspase-independent pathway . A new aspect of function of MMPs has emerged from the reports of MMPs being present within mammalian cell nuclei [66, 67]. It was recently shown that MMP-3 can translocate to the nucleus in vitro, where it was reported to exert pro-apoptotic functions mediated through its catalytic domain . The same report showed evidence of intranuclear MMP-2 and MMP-3 on human liver sections.
Studies in multiple sclerosis and rheumatoid arthritis have demonstrated that cleavage of particular collagen fragments by MMPs leads to the exposure of highly immunoreactive epitopes [68, 69]. These findings led to the proposition of a model for the generation of autoantibodies, termed the 'remnant epitope generate autoimmunity' (REGA) model [69, 70]. Briefly, the underlying concept is that in an inflammatory context, a local increase in proteolytic activity generates a large number of substrate fragments for presentation by activated antigen-presenting cells, including exposed cryptic antigen epitopes. This leads to both quantitative and qualitative changes in the local antigen repertoire. Although highly speculative, one could envision a situation in which dysregulation of MMP activity leads to a quantitative increase in the exposure of such cryptic epitopes. Furthermore, qualitative alterations in ECM composition could lead to cleavage of substrates not normally found in this location, causing the appearance of novel epitopes within the matrix. In the face of a persisting inflammatory process, such as evolving lupus nephritis, quantitative and qualitative changes in antigen repertoire might conceivably increase production of autoantibodies against matrix structures. Alternatively, alterations in glomerular membrane composition could favour the deposition of immune complex-associated structures such as nucleosomes, thus accelerating the formation of EDS-like structures within the membranes.
Central to the pathogenesis of lupus is continuous activation and proliferation of B-lymphocytes and T-lymphocytes with specificity for self-structures such as exposed chromatin fragments. Such structures may also serve as renal targets for the induced autoimmunity. Encounters with these antigens initiate proinflammatory signalling cascades, recruiting effector cells of the innate immune system, including monocytes/macrophages and neutrophils. As part of this inflammatory process, several MMPs and TIMPs are secreted by activated infiltrating cells and by cells intrinsic to the inflamed site, facilitating penetration into the tissue and structural remodeling as part of the healing process . An inflammatory reaction invariably causes local cellular decay, serving as a potential reservoir for exposed self-structures, including nuclear antigens. Chromatin structures derived from dead cells are found deposited as EDSs in glomerular membranes in lupus kidneys, where they co-localize with deposited autoantibodies . Ingestion of chromatin-containing immune complexes by infiltrating macrophages could conceivably upregulate MMP secretion through activation of the Toll-like receptor 9 signalling pathway [72, 73]. Persistently increased glomerular MMP activity could therefore be the result of an inflammatory process that is maintained by retained necrotic or apoptotic cellular debris. In turn, excessive matrix degradation by the MMPs would facilitate the deposition of immune complexes by compromising the integrity of the glomerular membranes. In this manner, the combined presence of autoreactive lymphocytes and an inflammatory process that exposes the inciting autoantigens allows the translation of a latent systemic autoreactivity to a focused end organ inflammatory disease. Increased MMP activity forms part of a spectrum of changes at the site of inflammation that ensures continued engagement of the innate immune system and progression of local tissue damage.
MMP inhibitory strategies have been tested in animal models of a number of chronic inflammatory diseases, including chronic obstructive pulmonary diseases, inflammatory bowel disease, rheumatoid arthritis and atherosclerosis. The progress of various such trials was recently reviewed by Hu and coworkers . For glomerulonephritis, MMP inhibition has exhibited promising results in rat anti-Thy 1.1 nephritis , but several key parameters in such a strategy remain ill defined, including the target MMP(s), timing and duration of intervention, specificity, dosage and delivery system. A more rigorous understanding of the spectrum of in vivo biochemical roles played by MMPs/TIMPs might be a prerequisite for the development and success of such targeted experimental and pharmacological interventions.
Our knowledge about the role played by MMPs within the context of lupus nephritis remains sparse and inconclusive. Studies in murine lupus-prone strains are underway and will hopefully shed light on this. The evidence that MMPs and TIMPs might be involved in the regulation of apoptosis provides further cause to look more closely into the matter of MMP activity, because disturbances in the clearance of apoptotic material is thought to be among the central elements in the development of lupus [74, 75]. Also, by forming a part of the Toll-like receptor mediated response to danger signals such as necrotic chromatin, increased MMP activity could be an important factor in initiating end organ manifestations of an autoimmune response.
Identifying the signalling pathways that are involved in inducing the observed alterations in MMP expression may contribute to our understanding of the initiation of kidney damage in lupus nephritis. Hopefully, this might pave the road to therapeutic strategies directed at preventing the development of glomerulonephritis and kidney failure in lupus patients.
a disintegrin and metalloproteinase
electron dense structure
promyelocytic leukaemia zinc finger protein
systemic lupus erythematosus
tissue inhibitor of metalloproteinase
We thank Dr Jan-Olof Winberg for critical review of the manuscript.