Bacterial and human peptidylarginine deiminases: targets for inhibiting the autoimmune response in rheumatoid arthritis?
© BioMed Central Ltd 2010
Published: 2 June 2010
Skip to main content
© BioMed Central Ltd 2010
Published: 2 June 2010
Peptidylarginine deiminases (PADs) convert arginine within a peptide (peptidylarginine) into peptidylcitrulline. Citrullination by human PADs is important in normal physiology and inflammation. Porphyromonas gingivalis, a major pathogen in periodontitis, is the only prokaryote described to possess PAD. P. gingivalis infection may generate citrullinated peptides, which trigger anti-citrullinated peptide antibodies. In susceptible individuals, host protein citrullination by human PADs in the joint probably perpetuates antibody formation, paving the way for the development of chronic arthritis. Blockades of bacterial and human PADs may act as powerful novel therapies by inhibiting the generation of the antigens that trigger and sustain autoimmunity in rheumatoid arthritis.
Arginine is a positively charged, hydrophilic amino acid that is often found on the surface of proteins, where it participates in ionic interactions with other amino acid side chains and forms stabilizing hydrogen bonds with both the peptide backbone and amino acid side chains. These characteristics make it a key amino acid in the three-dimensional organization of proteins and in the interaction with other biological molecules. Hence, post-translational modification of arginine can alter the three-dimensional protein structure and function and potentially expose previously hidden epitopes to the immune system. Deimination (citrullination) of arginine side chains (peptidylarginine) to form peptidylcitrulline is one of many recognized post-translational modifications of this amino acid. This post-translational conversion is catalyzed by the family of peptidylarginine deiminase (PAD) enzymes. The process of protein citrullination plays a vital role in normal physiology, in which it is involved in the formation of rigid structures such as hair, skin, and myelin sheaths . Aberrant citrullination has been observed in diseases of the skin and nervous system and in inflammatory arthritides, of which rheumatoid arthritis (RA) is one example . Despite the ubiquity of citrullinated proteins, the autoantibody response to citrullinated proteins is largely restricted to RA . The switch that leads to the generation of antibodies to citrullinated peptides and thus loss of immune tolerance to citrullinated proteins is likely to involve a complex interplay of individual genetic and environmental factors.
Localization and function of human peptidylarginine deiminase enzymes
Epidermis, hair follicles, arrector pili muscles, and sweat glands
Citrullination of filaggrin and keratin, facilitating proteolysis and crosslinking of the proteins and contributing to skin cornification. Maintains hydration of stratum corneum and epidermis barrier function.
Differentiation of hair follicles.
Brain astrocytes, sweat glands, arrector pili muscles, skeletal muscle, spleen, macrophages, monocytes, epidermis, synovial tissue, and synovial fluid
Citrullination of myelin basic protein in the brain and spinal cord, promoting electrical insulation of myelin sheaths.
Citrullination of vimentin in apoptotic monocytes and macrophages.
Upper layers of epidermis and hair follicles
Citrullination of trichohyalin, contributing to directional hair growth.
Hematopoietic cells and inflamed rheumatoid synovium
Citrullination of transcriptional coactivator p300 and histones H2A, H3, and H4, regulating gene expression by chromatin remodelling. Citrullination of fibrin, contributing to chronic inflammation in rheumatoid arthritis.
P53-dependent citrullination of proteins following DNA damage, translocation of histone chaperone nucleophosmin, and p53- mediated inhibition of tumor cell growth.
Ovary and testis tissue and peripheral blood leukocytes
Amino acids known to be conserved in PAD enzymatic activity are not conserved in PAD6. Function and enzymatic activity remain Unclear.
The best-established autoantigens in RA include α-enolase, fibrinogen, vimentin, and type II collagen (reviewed in ) and all are efficiently deiminated by mammalian PADs. In theory, citrullinated peptides from these antigens could also be generated by PPAD, although this has yet to be demonstrated experimentally. Alpha-enolase is of particular interest in this respect because it is highly conserved among eukaryotes and prokaryotes. A sequence of nine amino acids (Asp-Ser-Arg-Gly-Asn-Pro-Thr-Val-Glu) spanning the immunodominant epitope on the peptide known as citrullinated enolase peptide-1 (CEP-1) is 100% identical to the corresponding region in P. gingivalis enolase, and affinity-purified antibodies to CEP-1 react with recombinant enolase citrullinated in vitro from both humans and P. gingivalis , providing an attractive target for molecular mimicry between human and bacterial species.
The rationale for considering both human and P. gingivalis PADs in the etiology and pathology of RA is also based on epidemiological data suggesting an association between the two diseases (reviewed in ). Periodontitis and RA are chronic inflammatory disorders characterized by erosion of bone and production of pro-inflammatory cytokines. The reported prevalence of periodontitis is highly variable; in one large study of the American population, the prevalence was 4.2% . Epidemiological studies have shown that RA is more prevalent among patients with periodontal disease (3.95%) than in the general population (1%) . In addition, patients with RA have a higher frequency of advanced periodontal disease than the general population . P. gingivalis, Treponema denticola, and Tannerella forsythia are some of the major Gram-negative bacteria that exist as part of a complex bacterial biofilm in the gingival crevice and are linked to the development and progression of periodontitis but can also be found in lower numbers in periodontally healthy subjects . Long-term plaque accumulation and an interplay of host and bacterial factors result in chronic inflammation and tissue damage. Destruction of the adjacent bone and periodontal ligament attachment may eventually lead to tooth loss . P. gingivalis antibody levels have been shown to correlate with anti-CCP (anti-cyclic citrullinated peptide) antibody titres , making this periodontopathic oral bacterium an attractive candidate environmental trigger in the development of RA.
Several research groups have reported an increased variety and number of oral bacterial DNA and antibodies targeting these bacteria in serum and synovial fluid of patients with RA and other inflammatory joint diseases compared with controls (non-inflammatory arthritides or healthy donors) [15–19]. Oral bacterial DNA could reach the joint as free DNA or intracellularly in immune cells. Owing to the stringent growth requirements of live oral bacteria, their presence in the joint is unlikely, and no viable organisms have been obtained from synovial fluid . However, these observations need to be interpreted with caution since many bacterial antibody assays using whole-bacterium lysates are of questionable specificity, and the same applies to polymerase chain reaction-based detection and DNA-DNA hybridization using a complex nucleic acid mixture containing an excess of human DNA. A number of antibiotics used in the treatment of periodontitis, such as tetracyclines and clarithromycin, are efficacious in the treatment of RA [20–24], although to date there has been no direct evidence that this therapeutic effect is due to their anti-bacterial activity. For example minocycline has anti-inflammatory and anti-apoptotic effects that are separate from its anti-bacterial role and that are mediated by inhibition of nitric oxide synthase , matrix metalloproteinases , and caspases . As will be discussed below, minocycline and other tetracycline derivatives may also be direct inhibitors of human PAD4  and P. gingivalis arginine-gingipains , which are potent proteinases and major virulence factors in periodontal disease.
In normal physiology, PAD enzymes are involved in regulatory processes such as epidermal differentiation, maturation of hair follicles, insulation of nerve fibers, and epigenetic regulation. Aberrant citrullination contributes to skin diseases such as psoriasis and neurological disorders such as multiple sclerosis, Alzheimer disease, and prion disease [30–32]. Citrullination of histones and other nuclear proteins by PAD4 is involved in transcriptional regulation and response to cellular stresses and contributes to the innate immune response through the formation of neutrophil extracellular traps [33–36]. Recently, citrullination of various chemokines has been shown to have functional roles in receptor binding and signalling, proteolytic cleavage, and extravasation of neutrophils [37, 38]. Furthermore, citrullination appears to play a role in the coagulation system and associated pathways, and this is supported by the findings that in vitro citrullinated fibrinogen shows impaired thrombin-catalyzed fibrin polymerization  and in vitro citrullination of antithrombin with PAD4 abolishes its thrombin-inhibitory activity . Both citrullinated fibrin(ogen) and citrullinated antithrombin were detected in patients with inflammatory arthritis [40, 41].
Citrullination is thus a widespread phenomenon in normal physiology and inflammation, although targeting citrullinated proteins for an autoimmune response is relatively restricted to RA as shown by the high specificity of anti-citrullinated peptide antibodies for RA . Therefore, it is important to consider which of the deiminases are used for generating the antigens that drive this autoimmunity. On the transcriptional level, various single-nucleotide polymorphisms in the PADI4 gene have been associated with RA in Asian but not in Caucasian populations (reviewed in ). Suzuki and colleagues  showed that the presence of the disease-associated PADI4 haplotype led to a more stable mRNA, which they suggested increased PAD4 expression and thus levels of citrullinated proteins. However, as PAD inhibitors would work on the post-transcriptional level, we will focus on the expression of PAD enzymes. PAD2 and PAD4 expression has been demonstrated in rheumatoid synovium  and synovial fluid cells  and extracellularly in synovial fluid . PAD4 differs from other PAD isotypes in its capacity to undergo nuclear translocation due to the presence of a nuclear localization sequence and this translocation has been shown to be induced by tumor necrosis factor-alpha in murine and human oligodendroglial cell lines . PAD expression in the synovial tissue is not specific to RA. It occurs in a variety of inflammatory synovitides  and diseases such as inflammatory bowel disease, polymyositis, and interstitial pneumonia . While PAD2 is expressed in the synovia of both patients with inflammatory arthritis and osteoarthritis (OA), PAD4 is predominantly expressed in the synovia of patients with inflammatory arthritides rather than OA . The converse was observed in the extracellular compartment, where Kinloch and colleagues  showed the presence of PAD4 in the synovial fluid of patients with RA, spondyloathropathies, and OA, while PAD2 expression was found in both groups of patients with inflammatory arthritis but was notably absent in those with OA. PAD2 and PAD4 expression in the synovium correlates with inflammatory cell infiltration, synovial lining thickness, and vascularity of the deep synovium . Foulquier and colleagues  demonstrated PAD2 and PAD4 in close proximity to citrullinated fibrin deposits, although simultaneous detection of the two enzymes in the same area was rare.
P. gingivalis, considered a primary pathogen in chronic periodontitis, is a Gram-negative, non-motile anaerobic bacterium that is the only prokaryote described to date to express a functional endogenous PAD enzyme . To date, investigations of bacterial deiminases have focused mainly on enzymes that use free, non-peptidyl arginine or arginine derivatives such as arginine deiminase (ADI). ADIs are enzymes that catalyze the deimination of free arginine to citrulline, releasing ammonia. They are key enzymes in the widespread anaerobic pathway of arginine degradation and many pathogenic microorganisms use this pathway for energy production. Since ADIs are missing in higher eukaryotes, the enzyme constitutes a potential anti-parasitic and anti-bacterial drug target . The other group of structurally and functionally related enzymes produced by most bacterial species consists of agmatine deiminases (agmatine iminohydrolases, or AIHs). AIHs deiminate agmatine (a decarboxylation product of arginine) to N-carbamoylputrescine and ammonia.
Unlike mammalian enzymes, PPAD is able to deiminate both free arginine and peptidylarginine ( and our own unpublished observations) and preferentially targets carboxy-terminal arginine, although internal citrullination cannot be excluded. Furthermore, deimination by human PAD is calcium-dependent in contrast to that by PPAD, which does not appear to require any specific cofactors ([4, 52] and our own unpublished observations). P. gingivalis has been shown, however, to increase intracellular calcium concentrations by cleavage of proteinaseactivated receptor 2 (PAR 2), a G protein-coupled receptor found on the neutrophil surface, which may in turn promote human PAD activation .
The physiological role of PPAD is unclear. It was suggested that production of ammonia during deimination enhances the survival of P. gingivalis within the periodontal pocket . Indeed, ADI- and AIH-catalyzed ammonium production among bacterial species is known to act as a virulence factor, promoting the survival of microbial pathogens in the host environment. Ammonia neutralizes acidic environments and thereby optimizes gingipain and PPAD function, inactivates hemagglutinins, promotes ATP production, and has negative effects on neutrophil function [4, 54]. Furthermore, it can be speculated that PPAD acts as a virulence factor by generating citrullinated peptides, which may assist the bacterium in spreading and circumventing the humoral immune response. However, the requirements for citrullination by PPAD have not been well investigated to date and it is unknown whether the citrullinated peptides are immunogenic.
Thus, we conclude that PPAD may be more relevant to the initiation of autoimmunity at a site distant from the joint, such as the gingiva, and that PAD2 and PAD4 are important in generating autoantigens that perpetuate autoimmunity in RA once tolerance is breached. Further work is required to identify the regulation and substrate specificity of each enzyme in order to establish a more precise role in the autoimmune response.
Although PAD4 has been most extensively studied as a potential therapeutic target in RA (mainly based on the availability of a crystal structure ), PAD2 may also be important. It is proposed that selective inhibition of PAD would reduce the levels of citrullinated proteins and consequently suppress the humoral immune response directed to citrullinated antigens in RA. Because PAD4 has an important physiological role in regulating gene expression and PAD4 translocates into the nucleus from the cytosol, potential inhibitors may need to be selective for the extracellular compartment or other PAD isotypes to avoid unwanted effects on gene transcription. It is, however, not known whether intracellular or extracellular PAD is important in the pathophysiology of RA.
Paclitaxel is a chemotherapeutic agent that was initially derived from the bark of the Pacific yew tree. It inhibits angiogenesis by interfering with microtubule function in cell mitosis, migration, chemotaxis, and intracellular transport . In addition, in the millimolar range (half-maximal inhibitory concentration [IC50] = approximately 5 mM), paclitaxel inhibits PAD isolated from bovine brain . It has been shown to prevent the induction of collagen-induced arthritis (CIA) and cause significant regression of existing CIA . An open-label multicenter phase II study of paclitaxel in patients with RA was completed in July 2008, although results of this are still pending .
Other PAD inhibitors include F-amidine [N-α-benzoyl- N 5-(2-fluoro-1-iminoethyl)-l-ornithine amide], Cl-amidine [N-α-benzoyl-N 5-(2-chloro-1-iminoethyl)-l-ornithine amide], and 2-chloroacetamidine, of which Cl-amidine was reported to be the most potent (IC50 = 5.9 μM) . Ex vivo studies with F-amidine and Cl-amidine, using a cell line and an assay measuring PAD4-mediated citrullination of a nuclear protein and the resulting enhancement in binding to another protein, indicated that these inhibitors are bioavailable [59, 60]. F-amidine irreversibly inhibits PAD4 via the specific modification of Cys 645, an active-site residue that is critical for enzyme catalysis. Cys 645 acts as a nucleophile to form a thiouronium intermediate that is hydrolyzed to form citrulline. Cl-amidine and 2-chloroacetamidine are thought to act via a similar mechanism [59, 61]. Inactivation by F-amidine and Cl-amidine is calcium-dependent . In vitro studies with PAD4 have shown that calcium binding leads to a conformational change that moves Cys 645 and His 471 into positions that are competent for catalysis  and presumably reactive with F-amidine and Cl-amidine. This is of therapeutic importance as these compounds would therefore be expected to inhibit PAD4 in its activated state only at sites of inflammatory activity such as the synovium and not the inactive enzyme at other sites in the body, limiting toxicity . Willis and colleagues  recently showed that Cl-amidine treatment in CIA is able to inhibit clinical disease activity scores by 55%, 53%, and 42% in the 50, 10, and 1 mg/kg per day groups, respectively. Histological severity scores and complement C3 deposition scores paralleled the decreases in disease activity. In addition, mice receiving Cl-amidine showed reduced epitope spreading by peptide microarray, especially to citrullinated joint antigens. Interestingly, there were no changes in the percentages of T-cell, B-cell, or monocyte populations in treated mice compared with controls . These results suggest that Cl-amidine may represent a novel class of RA therapeutics that specifically target citrullination.
Bhattacharya and colleagues  demonstrated that human astrocytes subject to pressure showed elevated PAD2 levels, increased intracellular calcium concentrations, and increased citrullination. Treatment with the cell-permeable calcium chelating agent BAPTA-AM (1,2-bis-(o-Aminophenoxy)-ethane-N,N,N',N'-tetraacetic acid tetraacetoxymethyl ester) resulted in decreased intracellular calcium concentration and PAD2 levels. These results suggest that calcium modulation may be an alternative therapeutic strategy in modulating PAD activity and citrullination, although we would argue that this mechanism is too broad to be applicable in practice.
On the basis of the therapeutic use of tetracyclines in RA , Knuckley and colleagues  screened tetracycline derivatives (minocycline, doxycycline, tetracycline, and chlortetracycline) for their potential to inhibit PAD4 activity. Chlortetracycline was identified as the most potent inhibitor (IC50 = 100 μM) and was suggested to bind to a region distal from the active site . Streptomycin, an aminoglycoside antibiotic, was also tested because of its two guanidinium groups that could act as inhibitors of PAD4. Streptomycin was found to inhibit PAD4, though with a lower potency (IC50 = approximately 1.8 mM), and was suggested to bind within or in close proximity to the active site. The data suggest that these compounds could provide a valuable scaffold for engineering inhibitors with greater potency and selectivity.
The unique nature of PPAD in terms of its different amino acid sequence, cofactor requirement, and domain organization compared with human PADs (Figure 2), along with its location on the bacterial cell surface , would make this enzyme a potential target in the treatment of RA provided that its possible involvement in disease etiology or pathology is substantiated in future studies. Development of therapeutics targeting PPAD is further encouraged by advances in design and synthesis of inhibitors against parasite-derived ADI with potentials to be used as anti-parasitic agents . Since ADI, PADs, and PPAD are likely to use the same catalytic machinery to deiminate (peptidyl)arginine (Figure 2), a similar chemistry may be applied to develop PPAD inhibitors. The calcium-independent deimination of carboxy-terminal arginine residues specific to PPAD can be explored to develop highly selective compounds with little or no cross-reactivity with host enzymes.
McGraw and colleagues  reported that native PPAD, purified from the bacterial culture supernatant, was missing the N-terminus inferred from the DNA sequence because of proteolysis at the Arg43-Ala44 peptide bond. This might have been an artifact caused by the potent proteases, arginine-gingipains, which co-purified with PAD at the initial stages of protein purification, or might have true biological significance (for example, arising during export of the enzyme from the cell to form the mature protein). A recent paper on PPAD reported that the full-length, uncleaved form was unstable and had only 40% activity when compared with the truncated form of the enzyme . Future studies aimed at identifying the mature, in vivo form of PPAD and its enzymology are required in order to pin down the biologically relevant form of the enzyme and as such the more appropriate target for therapeutic blockade.
As the PPAD enzyme is not well studied, there are no published studies on possible therapeutic inhibitors. To gain insight into the catalytic mode of PPAD, McGraw and colleagues  tested various compounds that might interfere with the catalytic cysteine residue (Cys 351) or substrate binding. They reported that the serine- and cysteine-protease inhibitor leupeptin is able to completely inhibit PPAD at millimolar levels (5 mM), with other inhibitors such as thiourea, thio-L-citrulline, and the serine- and cysteine-protease inhibitor TLCK (N-alpha-p-tosyl-L-lysine chloromethyl ketone) being inhibitory at higher concentrations (12.5 to 50 mM) . Apart from the relatively low inhibitory potency, these compounds are either toxic (thiourea) or unselective (thio-L-citrulline is a potent inhibitor of nitric oxide synthase)  but nonetheless provide a basis for the development of more potent, specific inhibitors.
We have summarized a possible role for PPAD in breaking tolerance to citrullinated proteins, with human PAD2 or PAD4 or both maintaining the generation of citrullinated antigens in the joint. However, the evidence remains speculative and clearly requires further investigation of the mechanisms of activity of the enzymes involved and how the apparently unique PAD encoded by P. gingivalis could generate immunogenic peptides. If these hypotheses are further substantiated, PAD blockade has the potential to switch off autoimmunity at the point of initiation and inhibit the maintenance of the pathology in RA. Thus, inhibition of bacterial and human PADs could become the first treatment targeting the generation of the actual antigens that drive the disease.
citrullinated enolase peptide-1
N-α-benzoyl- N 5-(2-chloro-1-iminoethyl)-L-ornithine amide; F-amidine: N-α-benzoyl- N 5-(2-fluoro-1-iminoethyl)-L-ornithine amide
half-maximal inhibitory concentration (concentration of inhibitor that yields 50% inhibition)
Porphyromonas gingivalis peptidylarginine deiminase
This work was supported by the Arthritis Research Campaign (NW and PJV) and in part by grants DE 09761 and 1642/B/P01/2008/35 from the National Institutes of Health (Bethesda, MD, USA) and the Department of Scientific Research of the Polish Ministry of Science and Education, respectively (JP). The Faculty of Biochemistry, Biophysics, and Biotechnology of the Jagiellonian University Krakow is a recipient of structural funds from the European Union (grant number POIG.02.01.00-12-064/08 - 'Molecular biotechnology for health').