Immunopathologic differences of Sjögren's syndrome versus sicca syndrome in HCV and HIV infection
© BioMed Central Ltd 2011
Published: 19 August 2011
Skip to main content
© BioMed Central Ltd 2011
Published: 19 August 2011
A clinical picture of dry eye and dry mouth with the histological counterpart of focal lymphocytic sialoadenitis, usually detected in minor salivary glands, is considered the hallmark of Sjögren's syndrome. The association of sicca complaints and focal sialoadenitis can be also found in a number of other diseases, including some systemic viral infections. Among these conditions, chronic hepatitis C virus infection, associated with mixed cryoglobulinaemia and extra-hepatic manifestations, and HIV infection, particularly in the phase of diffuse interstitial lymphocytic infiltration, may mimic the clinical and histological aspects of Sjögren's syndrome. However, each disorder is characterised by specific, disease-related immunopathological aspects. Besides sicca complaints, the various disorders may also share a number of systemic extra-glandular features and the possible development of mucosa-associated lymphoid tissue lymphomas. This latter event represents in all of these diseases the final result of an antigen-driven chronic stimulation of B lymphocytes.
Sjögren's syndrome (SS) is a chronic systemic autoimmune disease mainly affecting the exocrine glands. For this reason, the definition of autoimmune exocrinopathy has been proposed in the past for this disorder . Behind the involvement of exocrine glands (pre-dominantly the lachrymal and the salivary glands), other nonexocrine epithelial lesions may be observed in a large number of patients. Consequently, the disease has been alternatively termed as autoimmune epithelitis .
Finally, autoantibody-mediated or immune-complex-mediated vasculitic lesions - compromising various organs or systems, such as the peripheral or central nervous system, skin, lung or kidney - may complicate the disease course, in a more limited number of patients. This justifies the inclusion of SS among the systemic autoimmune diseases . Furthermore, SS has received the attribute primary (pSS) when it appears alone, or secondary when it is associated with another well-defined systemic autoimmune disease, such as systemic lupus, rheumatoid arthritis or systemic sclerosis .
The presence of focal lymphomonocytic infiltrates in the target organs, particularly in the salivary and lachrymal glands, has been considered the hallmark of the disease. The focus consists of an agglomerate of inflammatory cells, mainly lymphocytes, which are located around the acinar and ductal structures of the glands. The presence of at least 50 mononuclear cells is the conventionally accepted definition for the focus . Because of the difficulty in obtaining lachrymal gland tissue, and the fear of causing facial nerve palsy or parotid fistulae in performing parotid gland biopsy, obtaining glandular tissue from minor salivary glands (MSGs) has been proposed as a more easily and less invasive approach for the histologic analysis of the target tissue . The biopsy of sublingual glands has been alternatively suggested, but it seems to be a more complicated surgical way to take a sample of gland salivary tissue . However, the existence of some important differences between the histological features found in major and minor salivary glands has been pointed out in several studies, and the biopsy of the parotid has been recently re-evaluated as an easy and safe method of obtaining salivary tissue .
A sufficient number of gland lobuli for histological examination can be obtained without any particular difficulty by performing a MSG biopsy on the lower lip. A permanent, although limited, sensory loss of the mucosa of the lower lip - occurring in a minority of patients - is the only known complication of a labial biopsy . Several authors also proposed different scoring systems of focal infiltrates observed in MSGs, and also the minimal score needed to define a diagnosis of SS [[5, 8, 9]]. Moreover, some authors proposed that the presence of a given focal score in MSGs could be the mandatory criterion to classify a patient as having SS . This point has been debated for a long time by the scientific community. The American-European Consensus Criteria for the classification of SS finally established that, among the six items composing the criteria set, either focal sialoadenitis at MSG biopsy (with a focus score ≥1 for 4 mm2 glandular tissue) or the presence of specific autoantibodies should be mandatory for the diagnosis of pSS .
Salivary glands (and also lachrymal glands) are not the exclusive inflammatory targets for SS. Sicca features may be part of the clinical picture of other disorders, in which a focal sialoadenitis, with histological characteristics evocative of SS, can be found . Besides sarcoidosis, where a focal granulomatosous sialoadenitis has been described, and the histological examination of MSGs can be useful in some cases to define diagnosis , even hepatitis C virus (HCV)  and HIV  infections may exhibit, in different phases of the disease, sicca complaints, with the histological counterpart of a focal sialoadenitis. This induced the American-European Consensus Group for the Classification of SS to list HCV and HIV infections among the exclusion criteria for SS .
In clinical practice, however, the presence of these overlapping features in the various disorders may generate some difficulties in the differential diagnostic definition. These difficulties can certainly be solved, alongside the viral investigations, by better defining the pathological differences between the focal sialoadenitis in the various conditions, using more sophisticated immunopathological techniques. In addition, the evidence that some viral infections may have salivary glands as one of the possible localisations, and that focal sialoadenitis may be the result of the local pathological process, again supports the theory - often proposed, but never completely proven - that some viral agent(s) could trigger the immunopathological cascade in pSS .
Salivary epithelial cells certainly play a crucial role in the pathological process of pSS. In an adequate environment of stressor agents and hormonal stimulation, and in the presence of a specific genetic background, these cells probably become susceptible to viral aggression. Different viral agents such as Epstein-Barr virus, nonhuman immunodeficiency retroviruses and, more recently, coxsackieviruses [15, 16] have been postulated to be capable of triggering pSS. The expression of Toll-like receptor 3 on salivary glands and epithelial cell lines derived from patients affected by pSS may suggest that the engagement of epithelial cells by virus may happen via Toll-like receptor 3 . The inadequate clearance of these viral agents and/or the consequent damage of the epithelial cells initiate a cascade of events that may lead to the self-maintenance of inflammatory mechanisms and induction of autoimmune manifestations. The insult may induce upregulation of type I interferon by epithelial cells and plasmacytoid dendritic cells, as demonstrated by IFNγ RNA overexpression in salivary gland tissue . Secondly, viral injury may induce apoptosis or necrosis of glandular epithelial cells, with the consequent release of autoantigens, which become available for professional antigen-presenting cells . The fact that epithelial cells may also work as nonprofessional antigen-presenting cells is still under debate . This hypothesis has been suggested by the evidence that epithelial cells, when activated, may express class I and class II MHC molecules on their surface , together with co-stimulatory molecules , and are probably able to engage T cells for the presentation of autoantigens once relocated from the nucleus to the cellular surface . Finally, epithelial cells are certainly important in T-cell recruitment since they produce both intracellular and vascular adhesion molecules  and different types of chemotactic factors, including chemokines.
Once T cells are first attracted into the glandular tissue, they assume the role of the main actors in the inflammatory scene , by perpetuating the recruitment of other inflammatory cells, mainly B cells, by expressing a restricted repertoire of T-cell receptors that can recognise autoantigens presented by antigen-presenting cells, and by activating macrophages (via the IFNγ signal). These latter cells act as the main agents responsible for further salivary tissue injury, mainly by producing TNFα .
The great importance of T cells in the immmunopathological scenario of pSS is strongly confirmed by the common observation that focal lymphocytic infiltrates are mainly constituted of T cells with a large predominance of CD4+ with respect to the CD8+ T cells (CD4/CD8 ratio ranging from 3:1 to 5:1) . B cells represent approximately 20% of the infiltrating cell population at least in some stages of disease . In addition, macro-phages, natural killer cells and dendritic cells are observed in more limited numbers . More recent studies have also shown that two other different T-cell subpopulations are represented in the salivary gland infiltrates. Th17 cells are a distinct CD4+ T-helper cell population expressing IL-17 that are strongly implicated in autoimmune diseases. Increased plasma levels of IL-17 have been observed in SS, and Th17 cells seem to be significantly represented in MSG infiltrates . Transforming growth factor beta (TGFβ), IL-23 and IL-6 are the main promoters of the Th17 differentiation and proliferation . TGFβ is also the pivotal differentiation factor of Foxp3+ T-regulatory cells, which seems to have an immunosuppressive role in the chronic immunopathologic process . T-regulatory cells have also been found in variable proportions in salivary biopsy specimens of patients with pSS .
Recent investigations have shown that the inflammatory cell presence, proportion and organisation may greatly vary in the disease course, and in various subsets of patients, according to disease severity and evolution . CD4+ T cells predominate in mild sialoadenitis and seem to be associated with the presence of a clinically significant articular involvement. The B-cell presence progressively grows from intermediate to severe histological lesions. The predominance of B cells in infiltrates and their organisation in the germinal-centre-like structure is strongly associated with hypergammaglobulinaemia, hypocomplementaemia, rheumatoid factor and autoantibody production, and, from a clinical point of view, with salivary gland swelling, vasculitic manifestations and lymphoproliferation . Foxp3+ T-regulatory cells are mainly represented in the intermediate grade of lymphocytic infiltration and decline in severe histological lesions [29, 30]. On the contrary, macrophages are more abundant in severe lesions, as well as dendritic cells. These latter cells are largely represented in more advanced lesions [26, 30], and particularly in the germinal-centre-like structure, where they appear to form a network that is essential for the organisation of the infiltrates [30, 31]. Finally, IL-17 protein expression progressively increases with a higher focus score, indicating an expansion of the Th17 subpopulation in more severe phases of the disease .
The passage from a predominance of CD4+ cells to that of B lymphocytes in glandular infiltrates is therefore characteristic of a more advanced severe disease pattern, which is correlated with systemic manifestations and higher risk of developing lymphoproliferative disorders .
B lymphocytes in salivary gland infiltrates in SS are mainly represented by polyclonal CD27+ memory B cells . Homing of this kind of B cell seems to predominate with respect to local proliferation of a few founder B cells . A large number of chemokines may all contribute to B-lymphocyte homing and chronic maintenance. A particular profile of chemokines, however, is predominantly active in SS. This profile is represented by the CXCL13 and CXCL12 chemokines, which specifically attract CD27+ memory B cells expressing the corresponding receptors (CXCR4 and CXCR5) . Recent data have shown a large expression of these receptors in the glandular infiltrates of patients with SS. The interaction of B cells attracting chemokines with their specific receptors has been suggested to be essential for B-cell recruitment and organisation in a tertiary germinal-centre-like structure .
Behind memory B cells there is a convincing demonstration of the contemporary presence of marginal zone (MZ)-like B cells within the lymphoid infiltrates in SS . These MZ-like B cells may work as reactive B cells against locally expressed autoantigens. Because of the permanent availability of autoantigens, the continuous stimulation of these autoreactive cells leads to the evolution from polyclonal to oligoclonal and then monoclonal selection, and finally to the development of mucosa-associated lymphoid tissue (MALT) B-cell lymphoma .
B-cell recruitment, survival, proliferation and organisation are strongly influenced in SS by the large production of B-cell activating factor (BAFF) and a proliferation-inducing ligand (APRIL) [33, 35]. In particular, enhanced levels of BAFF have been shown in most of the systemic autoimmune diseases, usually associated with B-cell hyperactivity. The highest plasma BAFF levels, however, have been found in patients with SS, and a strong local overexpression of this substance has been demonstrated in salivary gland infiltrates , particularly in patients with a high focus score. BAFF is produced locally by different cell types, including dendritic cells, T lymphocytes and macrophages, and certainly plays an important role in local B-cell proliferation, including that of MZ-like B-cell, germinal-centre-like formation, autoantibody production and probably B-cell lymphomagenesis .
Besides hepatocytes and lymphocytes, HCV seems to have a special tropism for lachrymal and salivary epithelial cells. HCV RNA has been found both in saliva and salivary gland tissue , and in situ hybridisation studies have clearly demonstrated that HCV is exclusively localised in the salivary epithelial cell cytoplasma . A chronic focal sialoadenitis, resembling that of SS, can be observed in approximately 50% of HCV-infected patients, while signs of mild inflammatory infiltration are present in a greater proportion of patients . Sicca symptoms, however, seem to be less frequent and milder in HCV-infected patients. These findings have stimulated a long debate on the possibility that HCV could be considered at least one of the candidate viruses to work as trigger agents for pSS. This hypothesis has been supported by several papers in which HCV infection appeared to be more prevalent in patients with pSS than in healthy controls (reviewed in ). Other data, however, have shown that the prevalence of HCV infection in patients with defined pSS was similar to that observed in the normal population, and that the overestimation previously reported could by ascribed to different classification criteria used in different studies, and to hypergammaglobulinaemia frequently present in the sera of patients with SS . Moreover, the co-existence of HCV infection and defined pSS (and lymphoma) in the same patients has been sporadically reported, and the demonstration that this association can be ascribed to chance alone is still under discussion . According to the American-European Consensus Criteria, however, evidence of HCV infection is an exclusion criterion for the classification of a patient as having SS .
The amount of information available on the characteristics of the focal infiltrates in salivary glands of HCV-infected patients is not as extensive as that accumulated in SS. This is undoubtedly due to the greater attention devoted to the predominance of liver involvement in HCV infection, and to the fact that features different from sicca complaints are more clinically significant in HCV infection with extra-hepatic manifestations. Histologic examination of salivary glands in HCV-infected patients shows different aspects with respect to those found in SS patients. Lymphocytic infiltrates often may be located in the pericapillary area rather than around the glandular ducts. In addition, a lack of damage (or mild damage) of the glandular tissue has also been reported [41, 44]. The lymphocytic subpopulations present in glandular infiltrates appear to be different, sometimes being represented by a predominance of CD8+ T lymphocytes, at least in some areas. More commonly, CD4+ T cells constitute the most represented population in the infiltrates. However, even in this latter case, the CD4/CD8 ratio is usually lower than that observed in SS patients with pSS . There is no demonstration of any translocation and expression of autoantigen peptides in salivary gland epithelial cells, and therefore the corresponding autoantibodies are not detectable in the sera of HCV-infected patients . On the contrary, serum cryoglobulins and hypocomplementaemia are usually found in a large proportion of HCV-infected patients, and are considered markers or predictors for the development of extra-hepatic manifestations of the disease, such as cutaneous vasculitis (cryoglobulinaemic purpura), peripheral neuropathy, glomerulonephritis and sicca syndrome .
The pathogenetic mechanism underlying focal sialoadenitis in HCV-infected patients has not so far been clarified. Transgenic mice carrying the HCV envelope genes for E1 and E2 proteins developed an exocrinopathy involving salivary and lachrymal glands . This study clearly indicates a direct role for these viral proteins in the pathogenesis of HCV-related sialoadenitis. Molecular mimicry between HCV-E2 protein and an antigenic protein present in exocrine epithelial cells has been suggested as a potential autoimmune mechanism inducing lymphocyte homing and activation . On the other hand, one could simply speculate that the HCV infection of the salivary epithelial cells may be the initial event that is sufficient to induce the activation of innate immunity with the consequent production of proinflammatory cytokines, such as INFγ and IL-2, in a way similar to that demonstrated to occur in HCV-infected hepatocytes .
Besides sharing similar clinical and serological features, such as cutaneous vasculitis, peripheral neuropathy and hypocomplementaemia, either patients with chronic HCV infection associated with mixed cryoglobulinaemia or patients with pSS may develop B-cell lymphomas with a higher prevalence than in the normal population . The most common type of B-cell lymphoma in both disorders is a MZ low-grade lymphoma, where the proliferating cells are rheumatoid factor-positive autoreactive B cells . A significant proportion of HCV-infected patients may also develop diffuse large B-cell lymphoma, probably by completely different pathogenetic mechanisms . In both diseases the low-grade B-cell lymphoma development represents a pathological model of an antigen-driven expansion from polyclonal/oligoclonal to monoclonal proliferation of B cells . The process is probably driven by autoantigen(s) in SS  and by viral antigen(s) in HCV infection . The fact that the process of low-grade B-cell lymphoma development is similar in both conditions is also supported by molecular studies demonstrating a similar restricted usage of genes encoding for heavy and light variable regions and similar somatic mutations of the complementary-determining region of the surface antigen receptor in monoclonal B cells from patients with SS and HCV-related mixed cryoglobulinaemia .
The site of development of these B-cell lymphomas is typically extra-nodal, since the salivary gland is the preferential site for lymphomas that appear in the course of SS, and the liver and salivary gland are the preferential sites for lymphomas developing in HCV-infected patients with associated sicca complaints . In both conditions, a possible evolution to diffuse large-cell lymphoma has been reported .
Clonality studies revealing monoclonal B-cell expansion in target tissues of both conditions are not strictly indicative of lymphoma . These clones may disappear after antiviral therapy in HCV-infected patients , or may persist in the same site for a long time without evolving to frank lymphoma. Clonality studies are therefore certainly useful at least to predict possible development of a frank lymphoma.
HIV-infected individuals are at an increased risk of developing associated rheumatic diseases . Before the widespread use of highly active antiretroviral therapy (HAART), retrospective studies calculated the rates of rheumatic manifestations from 11 to 72% . After the HAART implementation, rheumatic complications declined significantly, with some change in the pattern of the incidental diseases .
A SS-like clinical picture may be present in HIV-infected patients who develop diffuse infiltrative lymphocytosis syndrome (DILS). DILS may be present in 3 to 50% of HIV-infected populations . This great variability between the studies can be ascribed to ethnic differences, to the different criteria used to define the diagnosis (clinical vs. histological) and, finally, to the availability of effective antiviral therapy in the various populations described in the studies. Recent data strongly indicate that, similar to what has been reported for other rheumatic manifestations in HIV infection, the prevalence of DILS has also been remarkably reduced with the introduction of HAART therapy . DILS may mimic pSS because DILS also presents with bilateral painless parotid gland enlargement, lachrymal gland enlargement and sicca symptoms . DILS is characterised by circulating CD8+ T cells. The proliferation of CD8+ T cells is probably an antigen-driven process and leads to infiltration of multiple organs, and probably reflects an excessive host response to HIV . The condition usually manifests several years after HIV seroconversion and, besides the lymphocitic infiltration of salivary and lachrymal glands, is characterised by lymphocytic interstitial pneumonitis (31%), myositis (26%) and hepatitis (23%) . DILS differs from pSS by the fact that the occurrence of extra-glandular involvement is more frequent, whilst the presence of autoantibodies and rheumatoid factor is observed in a lower number of patients In addition, the two conditions differ in the nature of infiltrating lymphocytes (CD4+ T cells in pSS, CD8+ T cells in DILS) and in the association with different HLA haplotypes [[58–60]].
Interestingly, some cases of MZ indolent MALT lymphomas have rarely been reported in HIV-infected patients [[62–64]], among the large variety of incidental malignancies described in the course of the disease . MALT lymphoma remission was obtained in these cases after HAART, in a way similar to that observed in HCV-related and Helicobacter pylori-related MALT lymphoma after specific antiviral and antibiotic therapies . This observation again suggests that infection-related lymphomas derived from MZ B cells may share common antigen-driven mechanisms .
Main clinical, serological, histological, genetic characteristics of focal sialoadenitis
Primary Sjögren's syndrome
Hepatitis C virus
Moderate to severe
Mild to moderate
Moderate to severe
Mainly pulmonary, gastrointestinal, renal, and neurologic involvement
Mainly gastrointestinal and musculo-skeletal involvement
Mainly musculoskeletal, pulmonary, gastrointestinal, and neurologic involvement
Infiltrating lymphocytic phenotype
CD4+ T cells
CD4+ T cells
CD8+ T cells
High-frequency RF, ANA, anti-Ro/SSA and anti-La/SSB
High frequency of RF Very low frequency of ANA, anti-Ro/SSA and anti-La/SSB
Low-frequency RF, ANA
B8, DR2 and DR3
B45, B49, B50, DR11(DR5), and DRw6
The observation that MZ indolent MALT lymphomas may develop in all of these conditions has greatly contributed to a more precise understanding of the intriguing mechanisms of antigen-driven lymphoproliferation.
a proliferation-inducing ligand
B-cell activating factor
diffuse infiltrative lymphocytosis syndrome
highly active antiretroviral therapy
hepatitis C virus
mucosa-associated lymphoid tissue
minor salivary gland
primary Sjögren's syndrome
T-helper type 17
tumour necrosis factor
transforming growth factor beta.