CD154: the atherosclerotic risk factor in rheumatoid arthritis?
© BioMed Central Ltd 2013
Published: 22 February 2013
Skip to main content
© BioMed Central Ltd 2013
Published: 22 February 2013
Atherosclerosis, now regarded as a chronic inflammatory disease of the arterial wall, and its clinical manifestations have increasingly been associated with rheumatoid arthritis (RA), supporting the notion that autoimmune diseases and vascular disorders share common etiological features. Indeed, evidence pertaining to this matter indicates that inflammation and its multiple components are the driving force behind the pathogenesis of these disorders. Interestingly, CD154 and its receptors have emerged as major players in the development of RA and atherosclerosis, which raises the possibility that this axis may represent an important biological link between both complications. Indeed, CD154 signaling elicits critical inflammatory responses that are common to the pathogenesis of both diseases. Here, we provide an overview of the traditional and disease-related interrelations between RA and vascular abnormalities, while focusing on CD154 as a potential mediator in the development of atherosclerotic events in RA patients.
Although CD154 was initially recognized for its pivotal role in humoral responses, multiple lines of evidence now support its implication in various immune and inflammatory conditions such as rheumatoid arthritis (RA). CD154 activates numerous cells of critical importance in the pathogenesis of RA, inducing responses such as cytokine release, matrix degradation and autoantibody production, all of which promote disease development . Furthermore, CD154 mediates inflammatory events through its action on various vascular cells, leading to atherogenesis initiation and progression .
Interestingly, cardiovascular complications such as atherosclerosis and its clinical sequelae have increasingly been associated with autoimmune diseases. Indeed, RA patients exhibit increased morbidity and mortality rates, which are associated with cardiovascular events such as acute coronary syndromes originating from atherosclerotic complications . Overwhelming evidence now highlights the importance of inflammatory pathways in the pathogenesis of atherosclerosis, thereby supporting that both these diseases share common etiological components . Given its contribution to the pathophysiology of autoimmune diseases and atherosclerosis, CD154 may represent the biological link between both of these disorders as an important risk factor in the development of accelerated vascular complications described in RA patients .
In this review we illustrate the role of CD154 in RA and atherosclerosis, while highlighting its potential implication in the increased vascular events associated with autoimmune conditions. We also discuss other traditional or disease-related factors contributing to atherosclerotic events in RA patients.
CD154, also known as CD40 ligand, is a member of the TNF superfamily initially described on T cells  but also found on platelets, monocytes and dendritic cells, as well as nonhematopoietic cells including endothelial cells, smooth muscle cells, fibroblasts and others. CD154 was originally shown to play a significantly role in T-dependent B-lymphocyte responses . In addition to its key role in humoral immunity, CD154 also mediates a vast array of inflammatory pathways, as evident by its involvement in cellular immunity. These include priming and expansion of T cells and the activation of antigen-presenting cells and other vascular cells, whereby CD154 was shown to upregulate co-stimulatory molecules and cytokine production . These cellular events are also the main mechanisms by which CD154 regulates numerous inflammatory disorders, including RA and vascular diseases.
CD40, a glycoprotein from the TNF receptor family, is the classical high-affinity receptor for CD154. CD40 is constitutively or inducibly expressed by most cells of the vascular and immune system (hematopoietic cells and nonhematopoietic cells) and represents the main signaling molecule in the CD154/CD40 receptor-ligand pair . This interaction is required for immunoglobulin isotype switching during the immune response. In fact, patients suffering from the X-linked hyperimmunoglobulin-M syndrome, which results from a genetic mutation in the CD154 gene, fail to produce the immunoglobulins IgG, IgA and IgE as a consequence of deficient CD40 signaling in B cells . Indeed, during humoral immunity, a tight interplay between dendritic cells, T lymphocytes and B lymphocytes occurs, throughout which the activation of CD40 provides a crucial signal for the activation, differentiation and secretion of immunoglobulins by B cells .
In addition to its pivotal role in adaptive immunity, CD40 ligation generally leads to cell survival and inhibition of apoptosis, critical features of inflammatory cell resistance and exacerbation during CD154-mediated autoimmune and vascular diseases. These responses are mainly dependent upon the activation of the anti-apoptotic proteins Bcl-XL, A20, Bfl-1 and Mcl-1, which protect against Fas ligand and TNF-induced cell death . CD40 signaling also plays an important role in cell-mediated immunity, through its involvement in the upregulation of a plethora of proinflammatory adhesion molecules, cytokines, chemokines, matrix metalloproteinases (MMPs) and procoagulants. For instance, CD40 ligation on synovial cells induces TNFα and IL-1β production, critical inflammatory mediators of RA pathogenesis .
The CD154/CD40 axis also regulates the expression and activation of MMP-1, MMP-9 and MMP-3 on monocytes, which contribute to a deleterious degradative cycle in RA [13, 14]. Through these inflammatory pathways, and multiple others, CD40 signaling has been linked to RA development. Indeed, CD154/CD40 signaling plays a critical role in the initiation and progression of the mouse collagen-induced arthritis model, as demonstrated by both pharmacological and genetic approaches (this aspect is also discussed in further detail below) [15, 16]. Moreover, CD40 activation on endothelial cells triggers the release of various inflammatory mediators of critical importance in the initiation and development of vascular disorders such as atherosclerosis .
The αIIbβ3 integrin is abundantly expressed on the surface of platelets and mediates platelet aggregation and adhesion. Binding to its natural ligands, such as fibrinogen, is dependent upon inside-out-mediated conformational activation of the molecule, a phenomenon shared by all members of the integrin family. Interestingly, a KGD sequence can be found within the extracellular domain of the CD154 molecule, thereby allowing binding to the KGD recognition motif of αIIbβ3.
Binding of CD154 to αIIbβ3 was shown to induce phosphorylation of tyrosine residues within the cytoplasmic domain of the β3 subunit and appears essential for thrombus stabilization in vivo [18, 19]. Indeed, CD154-/- mice exhibit unstable thrombi, which can be overcome by infusion of wildtype recombinant human CD154 and not CD154 specifically mutated at the site of interaction with αIIbβ3 . These results highlight the importance of the CD154/αIIbβ3 interaction in platelet function and thrombus formation, although additional studies are needed to further consolidate the implication of this new dyad in thromboinflammatory reactions.
The fibronectin α5β1 integrin receptor was also shown to bind CD154 . Cells of the undifferentiated human monocytic U937 cell line can interact with soluble CD154 (sCD154) in a CD40-independent and αIIbβ3-independent manner. Binding appears to be mediated by α5β1, since preincubation with anti-α5β1 antibodies or soluble α5β1 reverses the interaction of sCD154 to this cell line. Interestingly, CD154 can interact with both CD40 and α5β1 concomitantly, as co-incubation of sCD154 with soluble CD40 does not affect binding to α5β1, indicating that CD40 and α5β1 share distinct binding residues for CD154 [20, 21].
Unlike αIIbβ3, CD154 interacts with constitutively inactive α5β1, which is uncommon to the classical scheme of integrin outside-in signaling and activation. This observation was demonstrated by experiments in which activation of α5β1 by chemical agents such as DTT hinders the binding to sCD154. Moreover, bronchial fibroblasts obtained from asthmatic subjects have been previously shown to interact with CD154 from T cells in a α5β1-dependent manner, suggesting the existence of CD154/α5β1 cross-talk in inflammatory airway diseases such as asthma . Nevertheless, the physiological relevance of this interaction remains unexplored and additional studies are needed to fully characterize the exact contribution of this novel CD154 binding partner in inflammatory disorders.
The αMβ2 (Mac-1) integrin mediates firm adhesion of leukocytes to inflamed vessels by interacting with its endothelial cell counter-receptor intercellular adhesion molecule-1. CD154 is also able to interact with this integrin, and this interaction may represent an alternative pathway for CD154-mediated inflammation. Indeed, inhibition of this novel CD154 binding partner significantly attenuates leukocyte accumulation at sites of inflammation and reduces atherogenesis, indicating that CD154 may promote, at least in part, atherosclerotic lesions in a αMβ2-dependent manner. This hypothesis was recently demonstrated in an elegant study showing that specific targeting of this dyad with small inhibitory peptides significantly reduces atherogenesis and inflammatory cell recruitment, but does not affect thrombosis and immunity . These data imply that CD154/αMβ2 interactions play a specific role in inflammatory-driven diseases in which leukocyte recruitment and infiltration at the sites of lesions represent important hallmarks of disease initiation. Specific targeting of this interaction has now emerged as a potential treatment strategy against inflammatory diseases, as compared with global CD154 inhibition where immunodeficiency and bleeding complications could be observed.
Data from RA animal models convincingly support the role of CD154 in the pathogenesis of the disease, as anti-CD154 treatment was shown to attenuate inflammatory events and disease severity . Moreover, administration of agonistic anti-CD40 antibodies in mice exacerbates disease progression and IFNγ production by T cells . Gene silencing of CD40 through siRNA targeting prevents the development of the disease in mice, further supporting the contribution of CD40 in the pathogenesis of RA . The importance of the CD154 axis in RA is also highlighted by the levels of sCD154 found in patients, which correlate with disease severity and both IgM-RF and IgG-RF titers . Interestingly, in a case-control cohort study in Spanish females, an association between RA and a specific allele variant within the CD154 gene was established. Indeed, authors found that patients with RA express lower frequencies of the 24CAs allele than control patients, thereby linking the CD154 system to RA risk .
Atherosclerosis is a chronic disease of the vessels involving many inflammatory and immune events. In the presence of proper risk factors and inflammatory stimuli, the initial atherosclerotic lesion can develop into a growing fibrous plaque prone to rupture. If left untreated, plaque rupture may ensue, leading to thromboinflammatory reactions and vascular complications such as acute coronary syndromes, cerebrovascular diseases and others . Accumulating evidence indicates that CD154 is implicated in all stages of the pathogenesis of atherosclerosis since targeting of this molecule by both pharmacological and genetic approaches significantly reduces the size and lipid contents of atherosclerotic lesions [32, 33].
In the initial steps, CD154 is involved in endothelial cell activation, a critical step of atherogenesis initiation. CD154-dependent activation of endothelial cells induces expression of adhesion molecules and production of cytokines, which result in the recruitment and infiltration of inflammatory cells into the subendothelial space. Thereafter, CD154 further amplifies the inflammatory response by inducing additional cytokine release, production of MMPs and expression of tissue factor in cells of the growing atherosclerotic lesion, mainly macrophages and smooth muscle cells. These CD154-mediated cellular responses contribute to plaque instability and vulnerability to rupture, thereby initiating thrombotic events and clinical manifestations .
CD154 has therefore emerged as an independent and strong risk factor for atherosclerosis. Indeed, enhanced levels of sCD154 have been linked to acute coronary syndromes and correlate with disease prognosis . In addition, CD154 may be involved in the thrombotic events that follow atherosclerotic plaque rupture. In this regard, we have shown that sCD154 primes and enhances agonist-induced activation and aggregation of human platelets through a CD40-mediated TNF receptor-associated factor-2/Rac1/p38 mitogen-activated protein kinase-dependent pathway, which ultimately leads to platelet shape change and actin polymerization. Moreover, we have demonstrated that enhanced levels of sCD154 exacerbate thrombus formation and leukocyte infiltration in response to vascular injury, in a CD40-dependent manner . More recently, we demonstrated that the CD154/CD40 axis triggers NF-κB activation in platelets. This signaling pathway plays a critical role in platelet activation and aggregation upon sCD154 stimulation and may represent an important target against atherothrombosis .
RA patients were shown to exhibit increased mortality associated with atherosclerosis compared with the general population [3, 37]. The cardiovascular risk even precedes the formal American College of Rheumatology criteria-based diagnosis of RA, indicating an early association between both complications . Moreover, disease severity directly correlates with the risk of developing vascular complications, since more advanced disease states seem to predict greater cardiovascular morbidity in RA patients .
Given the immunoinflammatory nature of atherosclerosis, interest has been focused on the association between inflammatory autoimmune diseases and vascular events. Indeed, cardiovascular complications have been described in RA, systemic lupus erythematosus, ankylosing spondylitis, psoriasis, primary anti-phospholipid syndrome, systemic sclerosis or scleroderma and other disorders of inflammatory nature . Various stages of atherosclerosis, ranging from preclinical events to disease manifestations and complications, have been described in patients with RA. Endothelial dysfunction, the initial step in the development of atherosclerotic lesions, is detected early in RA patients, as indicated by impaired flow-mediated dilation. In longer disease durations, more structural damage is observed in the arteries, as measured by increased common carotid intima/media thickness . RA severity has been associated with prevalence and extent of calcified lesions in coronary arteries . Interestingly, a significant interaction was found between many atherosclerotic risk factors and RA parameters, suggesting a synergy between RA modulators and these traditional risk factors in the development and/or acceleration of atherosclerosis .
Common risk factors of rheumatoid arthritis and atherosclerosis
Anti-citrullinated protein antibodies
Anti-cyclic citrullinated peptides
Anti-heat shock protein 65
Anti-oxidized low-density lipoprotein
Monocyte chemoattractant protein-1
Autoimmune manifestations are the hallmark features of RA and are now increasingly reported in patients with atherosclerotic events. RF and ACPA are the main autoimmune antibodies present in RA. RF is directed against the Fc portion of IgGs, while ACPA are directed against fibrin, fibrinogen and vimentin post-translationally modified to contain the amino acid citrulline .
Even though RF can be detected in other diseases or in healthy individuals, it remains an important marker of RA in terms of diagnostic support and evaluation of disease progression risk [49, 50]. Moreover, anti-cyclic citrullinated peptide antibodies have also emerged as reliable diagnostic markers of early RA-associated events and can be used as sensitive test substrates for detecting ACPA in patients . Notably, anti-cyclic citrullinated peptide antibodies have been previously associated with subclinical atherosclerosis in patients with RA, indicating that they may represent important risk factors in the development of accelerated cardiovascular events in these patients .
Other autoimmune antibodies present at high levels in RA include anti-RA33 directed against heterogeneous nuclear ribonucleoprotein A2, anti-collagen directed against collagen II and antibodies directed against heat shock proteins (HSPs) . On the contrary, atherosclerosis was also shown to be associated with a number of self-antigens, including oxidized low-density lipoprotein, β2-glycoprotein I, as discussed below, and HSP60/65 [53, 54]. Interestingly, immunizing atherosclerosis-prone animals with the HSP60 autoantigen or infusion of lymphocytes directed against this particular antigen was shown to enhance disease progression. Auto-HSP60 antibodies are also detected in sera of patients with RA . Generation of autoantibodies in RA could therefore be implicated in enhancing atherosclerotic events in patients suffering with this disease.
In addition to their shared autoimmune manifestations, RA and atherosclerosis are also interrelated through their tight inflammatory nature. Indeed, both disease conditions are characterized by T-cell and macrophage activation. In addition, patients with RA exhibit an up-regulation of the inflammatory marker C-reactive protein, a strong biomarker of cardiovascular risk. Pro-inflammatory cytokines, including TNFα, IL-1, IL-6 and IFNγ, and chemokines such as monocyte chemoattractant protein-1 were also shown to be involved in the pathophysiology of RA and atherosclerosis [31, 56]. Moreover, both diseases show an upregulation of endothelial and immune cell adhesion molecules, as well as an increased production and activity of MMPs [31, 56].
Because of its significant role in the pathology of atherosclerosis and autoimmune conditions such as RA, CD154 could represent an important link between both conditions by contributing to the increased prevalence of vascular diseases seen in RA patients. CD154, both soluble and membrane bound, is upregulated in the synovial cavity of RA patients and could therefore initiate vascular inflammatory events or, at the least, enhance an already established vascular abnormality (Figure 2). Evidence that CD154 may be linked to vascular complications in RA patients was initially provided by a study assessing levels of sCD154 in RA and rheumatoid vasculitis, which is characterized by extra-articular inflammation of small and medium-sized blood vessels. Authors found that levels of sCD154 were significantly higher in RA patients who had vasculitis than those without, indicating that CD154 may represent an important etiological factor of vascular inflammatory development in these patients . Moreover, in a study aiming at investigating the association between RA and atherosclerotic events by assessing platelet, endothelial and coagulation activation markers, serum levels of sCD154 were significantly increased in RA patients as compared with controls .
Recently, a polymorphism in the CD40 gene was found to be associated with atherothrombotic manifestations in RA patients, thereby supporting the implication of this axis in the development of accelerated vascular complications in RA . Additional evidence for the contribution of the CD154 axis in the association between RA and atherosclerosis was also described in a study showing that abrogating vasoactive factors such as angiotensin II can affect vascular function and inflammatory markers in RA patients. The authors demonstrate that inhibiting the angiotensin-converting enzyme in RA patients ameliorates arterial endothelial function and downregulates plasmatic levels of soluble CD40 and TNFα . Downregulation of these critical inflammatory molecules may represent the underlying mechanism by which vascular functions are significantly improved in RA patients treated with angiotensin-converting enzyme inhibitors.
Growing evidence favors the implication of CD154 in the cross-talk between autoimmune diseases and atherosclerosis, contributing as such to the enhancement of vascular abnormalities in these conditions. CD154 could therefore represent an interesting target for preventive or therapeutic strategies aiming at decreasing atherosclerotic load in autoimmune diseases. Many traditional, autoimmune and inflammatory mechanisms have been targeted in the goal of improving vascular functions in patients with autoimmune disorders. Cholesterol-lowering drugs such as statins, also known for their anti-inflammatory actions, have shown beneficial anti-inflammatory effects with modification of vascular risk factors in RA patients . Statins also have beneficial effects in reducing RA disease activity itself, consolidating again the notion that both diseases are intimately linked . Inhibition of inflammatory pathways induced by the vasoactive factor angiotensin II also improves vascular functions in RA patients.
Interestingly, current RA therapies such as TNFα inhibitors (infliximab, adalimumab and etanercept) have been shown to be effective in controlling disease activity, while providing significant benefits in the management of vascular complications observed in these patients. For instance, positive effects on carotid intima-media thickness, arterial stiffness and endothelial dysfunction have been reported in RA patients treated with TNF antagonists . However, multiple studies have determined that TNF blockage increases total cholesterol levels (triglycerides, low-density lipoproteins and high-density lipoproteins) in RA patients, putting in doubt the level of efficacy of these treatments in reducing cardiovascular events in patients with autoimmune diseases such as RA . Moreover, nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs such as cyclooxygenase-2 inhibitors for the treatment of RA have been associated with an increased risk of developing cardiovascular events, indicating that these agents may not represent a suitable therapeutic option for decreasing atherosclerotic load in these patients .
Because of its critical role as a common factor in the pathogenesis of atherosclerosis and autoimmune diseases, blocking CD154 interactions may show beneficial results in the treatment of vascular complications associated with autoimmune diseases or in the treatment of autoimmune diseases themselves. Unfortunately, direct clinical evidence for the role of CD154 as a contributor to accelerated vascular complications in RA patients has been hindered by the fact that pre-existing trials using anti-CD154 antibodies induce thromboembolic complications in treated patients, perhaps through unwanted Fc activation at the surface of platelets . These side effects have impeded the continuation of ongoing trials, and no clinical data on the effect of anti-CD154 therapy on the occurrence of vascular complications in autoimmune patients have been provided. Further studies will be necessary to fully establish the role of CD154 in the development of accelerated cardiovascular events in RA patients. The development of novel anti-CD154 agents may render better clinical outcomes, while providing affirmation of this axis as a linker of autoimmune diseases and cardiovascular complications.
anti-citrullinated protein antibodies
heat shock protein
small interfering RNA
tumor necrosis factor.
Work in our laboratories is supported by the Canadian Institutes of Health Research and the Canadian Arthritis Network.