Author (year)[ref] Phase* | Study population, duration of remission or LDA (definition) | Number; type of joints | US modality, definition of synovitis (A-F) | Outcome¶ Risk estimates (95% CI) | Authors' conclusions | Limitations# |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Balsa (2010) [20] 2 | 97 RA in remission >2 months (physician's judgment); 88 controls | 42; PIP, MCP, wrists, elbows, shoulders, knees, ankles, MT, MTP | GSUS & PDUS A | Of RA in remission, 92% GSUS-positive and 42% PDUS-positive; 88% of non-arthritic controls GSUS-positive | Of sets ARA 1981, DAS28 and SDAI, the SDAI is closest to the absence of inflammation on US | j,o |
Brown (2006) [11] 2 | 107 RA in remission > 6 months (physician's judgment) | 8; MCP2-5, wrist (RC, IC, DRU, UC) of dominant hand | GSUS & PDUS B | 73% GSUS-positive 43% PDUS-positive | In many patients in remission, inflammation is found on US | o,x |
Brown (2008) [21] 2 | 102 RA in remission > 6 months (physician's judgment) | 8; MCP2-5, wrist (RC, IC, DRU, UC) of dominant hand | GSUS & PDUS B | PDUS predicts radiographic progression at one year: OR = 12 (3.3, 44) | Presence of PDUS predicts radiographic progression in joints of patients in remission | o,v,x |
Foltz (2011) [22] 2 | 85 RA in remission or with LDA > 2 months (DAS < 2.4) | 14; wrists, MCP2,3,5, MTP2,3,5 | GSUS & PDUS A | PDUS predicts flare: OR = 6.3 (2.0, 20); PDUS predicts radiographic progression: OR = 1.4 (1.1, 1.9) | Inflammation on PDUS predicts radiographic progression and flare of patients in remission or with LDA | o,q,v |
Ozgocmen (2008) [9] 1 | 52 RA of whom a subgroup in remission > 2 months (Preliminary ARA 1981 + DAS < 3.2) | 14; MCP1-5, wrists (USTL, RSTL) | GSUS & PDUS C | 62% of 32 patients (in ARA 1981 remission) PDUS-positive 58% of 31 patients (in DAS28 remission) PDUS-positive | PDUS inflammation is found for 2 different remission criteria sets, in a similar number of patients | i,j,k,l,o,r,t, |
Peluso (2011) [23] 2 | 48 early (7 months) RA in remission > 6 months (DAS < 1.6) 46 LSRA (118 mo.) in remission > 6 months (DAS < 1.6) | 12; MCP2-3, PIP2-3, wrists (RC, UC) | GSUS & PDUS Not given | 56% early RA GSUS-positive; 83% LSRA GSUS-positive; PDUS predicts flare: OR = 3.6 (1.4, 9.0) | PDUS shows predictive value for flare In many patients in remission, inflammation is found on US | g,i,l,n,o,p,r,t,u,v |
Saleem (2009) [24] 2 | 100 RA in remission > 6 months (DAS < 2.6) | 16; wrists (RC, UC,IC), MCP1-5 | GSUS & PDUS D | 88% GSUS-positive PDUS-positive 58% | In > 55% of patients in remission inflammation is found on PDUS | i,o,r,x |
Saleem (2010) [25] 2 | 47 RA in remission > 6 months (DAS28 < 2.6) of whom a subgroup of 20 patients is assessed also by US | 18; wrists, PIP, MCP | GSUS & PDUS F | In group that flared after 2 years, at baseline 88% GSUS-positive and 44% PDUS-positive. In group that did not flare after 2 years, at baseline 82% GSUS-positive and 45% PDUS- positive | In many patients in remission inflammation is found on PDUS, but does not predict flare | o,r,u,v,w,x |
Saleem (2011) [10] 2 | 128 RA in remission > 6 months (ACR 2011) | 6; wrist, MCP2-5 of the dominant hand | GSUS & PDUS D | Around 50% PDUS-positive when using ACR2011, DAS28, SDAI remission sets | For 3 different remission criteria sets a similar number of patients is PDUS-positive | c,h,i,j,k,l,o,p,r,t,u,v,x |
Scire (2009) [26] 2 | 106 early RA (<12 months), of whom 43 in remission > 3 months (DAS < 1.6) | 44; shoulders, elbows, wrists, MCP, PIP, knees, ankles, MTP | GSUS & PDUS E | 95% GSUS-positive, 41% PDUS-positive PDUS positivity predicts flare: OR = 13 (1.6, 104) | In many patients in remission, inflammation found on PDUS, predictive of flare | g,i,j,k,l,m,p,r,t,u,v |
Wakefield (2007) [27] 3 | 10 early (<12 months) RA in remission (DAS28 < 2.6) | 42; shoulders, elbows, wrists, MCP, PIP, knees,tibiotalar, MT, MTP | GSUS & PDUS Not given | 50% GSUS-positive and 15% PDUS-positive in clinically normal joints | In many RA-patients in remission, PDUS inflammation is found | i,n,t,x |