Skip to main content

Table 2 Characteristics of OA patients by willingness to undergo TKR

From: Determinants of patient preferences for total knee replacement: African-Americans and whites

 

Not willing (n = 208)

Willing (n = 585)

P valuea

Socio-demographic Characteristics

   

 Race, n (%) African-American

106 (51.0)

176 (30.1)

<0.001

 Age, mean ± SD, years

62.88 ± 10.64

62.28 ± 8.87

0.467

Education, n (%)

  

0.008

 ≤High School or GED

115 (55.3)

254 (43.4)

 Post-secondary/Associates/Bachelors

69 (33.2)

219 (37.4)

 graduate degree

22 (10.6)

109 (18.6)

Income, n (%)

  

<0.001

 <$10,000

39 (21.3)

76 (14.1)

 $10,000-$19,999

56 (30.6)

97 (18.0)

 $20,000-$29,999

21 (11.5)

88 (16.3)

 $30,000-$39,999

19 (10.4)

48 (8.9)

 $40,000-$49,999

16 (8.7)

47 (8.7)

 ≥$50,000

32 (17.5)

183 (34)

Employment status, n (%)

  

0.006

 Full time

40 (19.2)

174 (29.9)

 Part time

17 (8.2)

57 (9.8)

 Unemployed

34 (16.3)

48 (8.3)

 Disabled

40 (19.2)

92 (15.8)

 Retired

77 (37.0)

210 (36.1)

Health insuranceb, n (%)

   

 Medicare

93 (46.3)

227 (40.8)

0.181

 Medicaid

37 (19.0)

78 (14.2)

0.114

 Private/group

81 (42.0)

292 (52.9)

0.009

 No insurance

14 (7.6)

19 (3.5)

0.021

 Recruitment site, n (%) non-Veterans Affairs

196 (94.2)

543 (92.8)

0.2247

Knowledge, attitudes and beliefs

   

 Religiosity, mean ± SD

10.19 ± 3.78

9.59 ± 4.00

0.053

Knowledge of TKR: familiarity, n (%) yes

 Heard about hip/knee surgery

158 (76.7)

458 (79.0)

0.497

 Family or friend who had hip/knee surgery

160 (76.9)

498 (85.1)

0.007

 Good understanding of knee replacement

106 (51.0)

365 (64.9)

0.001

Knowledge of TKR: risks and benefits

How often death from knee replacement, n (%)

  

0.257

 Never

29 (14.7)

75 (13.4)

 

 Extremely rare

134 (67.7)

406 (72.2)

 

 Sometimes

32 (16.2)

79 (14.1)

 

 Often

3 (1.5)

2 (0.4)

 

How long in hospital after knee replacement, n (%)

  

0.023

 1 to 3 days

57 (28.2)

199 (34.6)

 

 4 to 7 days

79 (39.1)

250 (43.5)

 

 1 to 2 weeks

45 (22.3)

84 (14.6)

 

 >2 weeks

21 (10.4)

42 (7.3)

 

How long to recover from knee replacement, n (%)

  

0.378

 <2 weeks

1 (0.5)

3 (0.5)

 

 2 weeks to 1 month

9 (4.5)

30 (5.2)

 

 1 to 2 months

44 (22.1)

140 (24.3)

 

 2 to 6 months

78 (39.2)

233 (40.4)

 

 6 to 12 months

50 (25.1)

146 (25.3)

 

 >12 months

17 (8.5)

25 (4.3)

 

How much pain after recovery, n (%)

  

<0.001

 None

17 (8.5)

87 (15.4)

 

 A little

74 (37.0)

267 (47.2)

 

 A moderate amount

98 (49.0)

205 (36.2)

 

 An extreme amount

11 (5.5)

7 (1.2)

 

How much difficulty walking after recovery, n (%)

  

<0.001

 None

14 (6.9)

120 (21.0)

 

 A little

98 (48.0)

306 (53.5)

 

 A moderate amount

84 (41.2)

134 (23.4)

 

 An extreme amount

8 (3.9)

12 (2.1)

 

 Expectations of TKR, mean ± SD

44.48 ± 17.26

53.40 ± 13.90

<0.001

TKR utilization process, n (%) yes

 Doctor ever discussed surgery

65 (31.6)

213 (36.5)

0.204

 Referred to arthritis specialist

67 (33.0)

172 (29.9)

0.404

 Referred to surgeon

101 (49.3)

268 (47.0)

0.580

 Doctor recommended surgery

47 (22.8)

130 (22.4)

0.906

Trust in physicians, mean ± SD

38.62 ± 6.75

39.77 ± 6.65

0.034

Trust in healthcare system, mean ± SD

26.11 ± 6.17

25.32 ± 5.55

0.090

  1. a P value from Pearson chi square or t test. bIndividuals may be included in multiple categories. TKR total knee replacement, GED General Educational Development test