- Research article
- Open Access
Synovial fluid leukocyte apoptosis is inhibited in patients with very early rheumatoid arthritis
Arthritis Research & Therapy volume 8, Article number: R120 (2006)
Synovial leukocyte apoptosis is inhibited in established rheumatoid arthritis (RA). In contrast, high levels of leukocyte apoptosis are seen in self-limiting crystal arthritis. The phase in the development of RA at which the inhibition of leukocyte apoptosis is first apparent, and the relationship between leukocyte apoptosis in early RA and other early arthritides, has not been defined. We measured synovial fluid leukocyte apoptosis in very early arthritis and related this to clinical outcome. Synovial fluid was obtained at presentation from 81 patients with synovitis of ≤ 3 months duration. The percentages of apoptotic neutrophils and lymphocytes were assessed on cytospin preparations. Patients were assigned to diagnostic groups after 18 months follow-up. The relationship between leukocyte apoptosis and patient outcome was assessed. Patients with early RA had significantly lower levels of neutrophil apoptosis than patients who developed non-RA persistent arthritis and those with a resolving disease course. Similarly, lymphocyte apoptosis was absent in patients with early RA whereas it was seen in patients with other early arthritides. The inhibition of synovial fluid leukocyte apoptosis in the earliest clinically apparent phase of RA distinguishes this from other early arthritides. The mechanisms for this inhibition may relate to the high levels of anti-apoptotic cytokines found in the early rheumatoid joint (e.g. IL-2, IL-4, IL-15 GMCSF, GCSF). It is likely that this process contributes to an accumulation of leukocytes in the early rheumatoid lesion and is involved in the development of the microenvironment required for persistent RA.
Inhibition of T-cell apoptosis in the synovium of patients with established rheumatoid arthritis (RA) was first described in 1995 . Subsequent work contrasted the virtually complete inhibition of T-cell apoptosis in RA with high levels of T-cell apoptosis in gout . The phenotype of rheumatoid synovial T cells (Bcl-XL high, Bcl-2low) demonstrated that their survival was maintained by stromal mechanisms rather than by the common γ-chain cytokines, and IFN-β was identified as a key fibroblast-derived survival signal . In addition to their effects on T cells, both IFN-β and synovial fluid from RA patients delay neutrophil apoptosis [4, 5]. These observations led to the concept that inhibition of leukocyte apoptosis, mediated by an expanded fibroblast network in the rheumatoid joint, was an important mechanism that maintains the leukocyte infiltrate in RA and perpetuates disease .
We recently showed that patients with very early RA, within the first 3 months of symptom onset, have a synovial fluid cytokine profile that is distinct from those of patients with other forms of very early synovitis and of patients with established RA . The synovial fluid of patients with very early RA is characterized by elevated levels of cytokines that are survival factors for T cells (IL-2, IL-4 and IL-15) and neutrophils (granulocyte-macrophage colony-stimulating factor [GM-CSF] and granulocyte colony-stimulating factor [G-CSF]). We therefore sought to determine whether synovial fluid neutrophil and lymphocyte apoptosis was inhibited in patients with very early RA compared with patients with other very early inflammatory arthritides. We found that patients with very early RA had significantly lower levels of neutrophil apoptosis than did patients who developed non-RA persistent arthritis and those with a resolving disease course. Similarly, lymphocyte apoptosis was absent in patients with early RA, whereas it was seen in patients with other early arthritides. The inhibition of synovial fluid leukocyte apoptosis in the earliest clinically apparent phase of RA distinguishes this from other early arthritides.
Materials and methods
Patients were recruited through the rapid access clinic for early inflammatory arthritis at City Hospital, Birmingham, UK. Ethical permission was obtained and all patients gave written informed consent. All patients had one or more swollen joints and a symptom duration of 3 months or less. Patients with evidence of previous inflammatory joint disease were excluded. No patient had commenced a disease-modifying antirheumatic drug (DMARD) before initial assessment. Joints were aspirated under either palpation or ultrasound guidance. Patients were included in the study if adequate synovial fluid was obtained by palpation or ultrasound-guided aspiration/lavage at initial assessment using a method described previously . Patients were subsequently assessed at 1, 2, 3, 6, 12 and 18 months. If joint effusions were present at follow-up assessments, and if consent to a further arthrocentesis was obtained, then these effusions were aspirated. Patients were assigned to their final diagnostic groups at 18 months. Patients were classified as having RA in accordance with the 1987 American Rheumatism Association criteria , allowing criteria to be satisfied cumulatively. Although the 1987 American Rheumatism Association criteria have no exclusions, we excluded from the RA category patients with alternative rheumatological diagnoses explaining their inflammatory arthritis. Patients were diagnosed with reactive arthritis, psoriatic arthritis, and a number of miscellaneous conditions according to established criteria.
Synovial fluid cytospin preparation and assessment
When synovial fluid was directly aspirated from the joint, the number of leukocytes per millilitre of synovial fluid was counted using a haemocytometer; a cell count measurement was not performed when the sample was obtained by lavage. Synovial fluid cytospins were made within 30 minutes of joint aspiration or lavage . The short sample processing time minimized the potential for artefactual results due to apoptosis ex vivo. Slides were air dried and stained with Diff-Quik (Dade Behring AG, Düdingen, Switzerland). Cytospins were assessed by an observer who was blinded to clinical details of the patients. Leukocytes were identified on the basis of morphology. Apoptotic cells were identified on the basis of a condensed or fragmented nucleus. Apoptotic neutrophils were distinguished from apoptotic lymphocytes on the basis of acidophilic or basophilic cytoplasmic staining (Figure 1). Up to 500 cells on each slide were counted where possible. A minimum of 200 cells were counted or the sample was disregarded because of lack of precision.
Categorical variables were compared using the χ2 test. Numerical variables were compared between patient groups using the Mann-Whitney test. Spearman's test was used to assess the correlation between levels of neutrophil and lymphocyte apoptosis.
Synovial fluid was obtained at presentation from 81 patients with very early inflammatory arthritis. Characteristics of these patients at presentation are shown in Table 1. Seventeen patients developed RA. Of the 17 patients who developed a non-RA persistent inflammatory arthritis, the final diagnoses were unclassified inflammatory arthritis (n = 9), psoriatic arthritis (n = 3), arthritis related to connective tissue disease (n = 3), ulcerative colitis related arthritis (n = 1) and arthritis related to Behçet's disease (n = 1). Of the 47 patients whose disease resolved, the final diagnoses were unclassified inflammatory arthritis (n = 25), gout (n = 9), pseudogout (n = 3), reactive arthritis (n = 7), sarcoidosis (n = 1), ulcerative colitis related arthritis (n = 1) and psoriatic arthritis (n = 1). One of the patients labelled as having an unclassified resolving inflammatory arthritis fulfilled classification criteria for RA at presentation. This patient received an intramuscular injection of steroid after 10 weeks of symptoms, following which the patient remained in remission off therapy throughout follow-up. Patients whose disease progressed to RA were significantly older than patients who developed non-RA persistent synovitis or patients whose disease resolved. Patients whose disease resolved had a significantly shorter duration of symptoms at presentation compared with patients in the other two groups.
The following joints were aspirated at clinical presentation: knee (n = 60), ankle (n = 11), metacarpophalyngeal joint (n = 4), proximal interphalyngeal joint (n = 2), shoulder joint (n = 1), elbow joint (n = 1), wrist (n = 1) and talonavicular joint (n = 1). The knee was aspirated in 10 (59%) of the patients who developed RA, 15 (83%) of the patients who developed a non-RA persistent arthritis and 36 (76%) of the patients with resolving disease. There was no significant difference between the groups in terms of the numbers of patients who had the knee or another joint aspirated (χ2 test; P = 0.22).
Synovial fluid leukocyte apoptosis at clinical presentation
Levels of synovial fluid neutrophil apoptosis were available for 71 patients at their initial visit. For the remaining 10 patients the number of neutrophils was too low to quantify the percentage of cells that were apoptotic. Sixteen of the 71 patients developed RA, 15 developed non-RA persistent synovitis and 40 had resolving disease. There was a significant difference in the percentage of apoptotic synovial fluid neutrophils between patients who developed RA and patients in the other two groups (RA versus non-RA persistent synovitis, P = 0.02; RA versus resolving synovitis, P = 0.003; Figure 2a). The median numbers of neutrophils per millilitre of synovial fluid in the initial samples of patients in the three groups were as follows: 2.5 × 106 (interquartile range [IQR] 0.2–6.0 × 106) for patients with RA; 7.1 × 106 (IQR 3.1–22.6 × 106) for patients with non-RA persistent synovitis; 3.9 × 106 (IQR 0.04–11.4 × 106) for patients with resolving synovitis. Patients with RA had a lower absolute number of apoptotic neutrophils per millilitre in their initial synovial fluid samples (0.02 × 106 [IQR 0.003-0.09 × 106]) than did patients with non-RA persistent synovitis (0.14 × 106 [IQR 0.02–0.99 × 106]; P = 0.046) or patients with resolving synovitis (0.14 × 106 [IQR 0.02–0.54 × 106]; P = 0.023).
Levels of synovial fluid lymphocyte apoptosis were available from synovial fluid cytospin preparations of 75 patients at their initial visit. For the remaining six patients the number of lymphocytes in the synovial fluid sample was too low to quantify the percentage of cells that were apoptotic. Sixteen of these patients developed RA, 15 developed non-RA persistent synovitis and 44 had resolving disease. There was a trend toward a lower level of lymphocyte apoptosis in the initial samples of patients with very early synovitis that developed into RA compared with initial samples of patients whose disease resolved, but this did not achieve statistical significance (Figure 2b). The median numbers of lymphocytes per millilitre of synovial fluid in the initial samples of patients in the three groups were as follows: 0.9 × 106 (IQR 0.1–1.4 × 106) for patients with RA; 1.1 × 106 (IQR 0.8–5.0 × 106) for patients with non-RA-persistent synovitis; and 0.5 × 106 (IQR 0.1–1.6 × 106) for patients with resolving synovitis. There was no significant difference between the absolute numbers of apoptotic lymphocytes per millilitre in the initial synovial fluid samples from patients in the three groups.
Only an occasional apoptotic macrophage was seen, and there were no differences between groups in terms of apoptotic macrophages.
Longitudinal assessment of synovial fluid leukocyte apoptosis
Several patients underwent repeat joint aspiration during their follow-up. Results for synovial neutrophil apoptosis from follow-up joint aspirations were available for 16 synovial fluid samples from 10 RA patients, 25 samples from 11 of the patients with non-RA persistent synovitis, and 17 samples from 11 of the patients with resolving synovitis. The number of weeks after symptom onset at which these follow-up samples were collected is shown in Table 2. More neutrophil apoptosis was seen in a follow-up sample than at initial presentation in two of the 10 RA patients, six of the 11 patients with non-RA persistent synovitis and four of the 11 patients with resolving synovitis. Prior therapy with a DMARD or parenteral steroid was not associated with enhanced levels of synovial neutrophil apoptosis at subsequent follow up (Table 2). The maximum percentage of synovial neutrophil apoptosis observed for each patient is shown in Figure 2c. The maximum level of synovial fluid neutrophil apoptosis was significantly lower in patients with RA than in patients with non-RA persistent synovitis (P = 0.0004) or in patients with resolving synovitis (P = 0.002).
Results for synovial lymphocyte apoptosis from follow-up joint aspirations were available for 12 synovial fluid samples from seven RA patients, 26 samples from 11 of the patients with non-RA persistent synovitis, and 21 samples from 13 of the patients with resolving synovitis. The number of weeks after symptom onset at which these follow-up samples were collected is shown in Table 2. More lymphocyte apoptosis was seen in a follow-up sample than at initial presentation in two of the seven RA patients, four of the 11 patients with non-RA persistent synovitis, and seven of the 13 patients with resolving synovitis. Prior therapy with a DMARD or parenteral steroid was not associated with enhanced levels of synovial lymphocyte apoptosis at subsequent follow-up (Table 2). The maximum percentage of synovial lymphocyte apoptosis observed for each patient is shown in Figure 2d. There was a trend toward patients with RA having less synovial lymphocyte apoptosis than patients with non-RA persistent synovitis (P = 0.09) or patients with resolving synovitis (P = 0.054).
Levels of synovial fluid neutrophil and lymphocyte apoptosis in initial and subsequent samples in patients who developed either RA or non-RA persistent inflammatory arthritis are shown in Figure 2e and 2f. The highest levels of leukocyte apoptosis in patients who developed non-RA persistent inflammatory arthritis were seen within the first 20 weeks of symptom onset. Only one patient who developed RA had significant levels of neutrophil apoptosis (12%) and lymphocyte apoptosis (1.5%) in a synovial fluid sample obtained after 10 weeks of symptoms. Lymphocyte and neutrophil apoptosis were virtually absent from all other synovial fluid samples from RA patients, irrespective of disease duration.
There was a statistically significant correlation between the levels of neutrophil and lymphocyte apoptosis in the synovial fluid samples (data not shown; Spearman r = 0.26; P = 0.004).
The early phase of RA, within 3 months of symptom onset, was characterized by very low levels of apoptotic leukocytes within the synovial compartment. During this phase of disease, patients with very early inflammatory arthritis who eventually developed RA had a significantly lower level of synovial fluid neutrophil apoptosis than did patients whose disease resolved. In addition, synovial fluid lymphocyte apoptosis was rarely observed in very early RA. There was a trend toward a higher level of lymphocyte apoptosis in patients with resolving disease compared with those who had very early RA. The inhibition of synovial fluid leukocyte apoptosis that characterizes established RA is thus also apparent in the earliest clinically apparent phase of disease. It is likely that this process contributes to the accumulation of leukocytes in the early rheumatoid lesion and is important in the development of the microenvironment that characterizes established RA. Follow-up assessments over the first 18 months of disease revealed that leukocyte apoptosis was inhibited at all time points in patients who developed RA, despite the fact that a proportion of patients had been treated, before the follow-up arthrocentesis, with antirheumatic drugs that have been reported to induce leukocyte apoptosis [10, 11].
The mechanisms underlying the inhibition of leukocyte apoptosis in patients with very early RA remain undefined. In addition to IFN-β, other mechanisms for the rescue of leukocytes from apoptosis may operate in established RA. Exposure of CD4+ T cells to stromal cell-derived factor-1α(SDF-1α (produced by synovial fibroblasts)) renders T cells less susceptible to apoptosis induced by anti-CD3 stimulation  and to cytokine deprivation induced apoptosis . In Crohn's disease and experimental colitis, a role has been suggested for IL-6 trans signaling in mediating the inhibition of apoptosis in lamina propria T cells . The contributions of such mechanisms to the type 1 interferon mediated T-cell rescue that operates in the rheumatoid joint is, at present, unclear. However, it is likely that the high levels of common γ-chain cytokines (IL-2, IL-4 and IL-15) and of G-CSF and GM-CSF that we recently reported in the very early rheumatoid lesion  play a role in lymphocyte and neutrophil survival in this phase of disease. Although these factors are not present in the joints of patients who progress to non-RA persistent disease, synovial leukocyte apoptosis was partially inhibited in these patients. Therefore, other factors are likely to contribute to leukocyte survival in the very early phase of disease that eventually persists. Macrophage-derived IFN-α is a potent survival factor for T cells and neutrophils [3, 15]. Synovial macrophages may thus contribute to the inhibition of leukocyte apoptosis that is seen in early arthritides that progress to persistence.
The low level of leukocyte apoptosis in the initial samples of some patients whose disease eventually resolved was intriguing. A study of lymphocyte apoptosis during the course of a delayed-type hypersensitivity response  showed that levels of lymphocyte apoptosis change as the lesion develops, being absent during the generation of the response and present during its resolution. In patients with self-limiting inflammatory lesions, the level of lymphocyte apoptosis thus appears to depend on the stage of the process at which the lesion is sampled. Our results suggest a transient inhibition of lymphocyte apoptosis at early stages of the disease process in some patients with a resolving inflammatory arthritis. Potential mechanisms for this include the transient presence of soluble survival factors such as IFN-α.
In this study patients who developed RA were older than patients with other early arthritides. It has previously been reported that neutrophils from older individuals are more susceptible to spontaneous apoptosis than are neutrophils from younger persons, and that rescue from spontaneous and Fas-induced apoptosis by cytokines such as GM-CSF and G-CSF is less effective in neutrophils from older individuals than in those from younger ones [17, 18]. In addition, the rate of spontaneous lymphocyte apoptosis is enhanced in elderly individuals compared with younger individuals [19, 20]. Consequently, it is unlikely that the reduced leukocyte apoptosis observed in RA patients is a feature of their greater age compared with other early arthritis patients.
Synovial fluid leukocyte apoptosis is inhibited during the earliest clinically apparent phase of RA. This contrasts with other early arthritides, in which significantly higher levels of neutrophil apoptosis are seen in the early lesion. The inhibition of leukocyte apoptosis in the joints of patients with RA, within the first 12 weeks of symptoms, and the presence of apoptosis in the joints of patients whose disease resolves suggest that therapies that induce leukocyte apoptosis may be useful within the first few weeks of symptoms in patients at high risk for development of RA.
= disease-modifying antirheumatic drug
= granulocyte colony-stimulating factor
= granulocyte-macrophage colony-stimulating factor
= interquartile range
= rheumatoid arthritis
= stromal cell-derived factor-1α.
Firestein GS, Yeo M, Zvaifler NJ: Apoptosis in rheumatoid arthritis synovium. J Clin Invest. 1995, 96: 1631-1638.
Salmon M, Scheel-Toellner D, Huissoon AP, Pilling D, Shamsadeen N, Hyde H, D'Angeac AD, Bacon PA, Emery P, Akbar AN: Inhibition of T cell apoptosis in the rheumatoid synovium. J Clin Invest. 1997, 99: 439-446.
Pilling D, Akbar AN, Girdlestone J, Orteu CH, Borthwick NJ, Amft N, Scheel-Toellner D, Buckley CD, Salmon M: Interferon-beta mediates stromal cell rescue of T cells from apoptosis. Eur J Immunol. 1999, 29: 1041-1050. 10.1002/(SICI)1521-4141(199903)29:03<1041::AID-IMMU1041>3.0.CO;2-#.
Scheel-Toellner D, Wang K, Henriquez NV, Webb PR, Craddock R, Pilling D, Akbar AN, Salmon M, Lord JM: Cytokine-mediated inhibition of apoptosis in non-transformed T cells and neutrophils can bedissociated from protein kinase B activation. Eur J Immunol. 2002, 32: 486-493. 10.1002/1521-4141(200202)32:2<486::AID-IMMU486>3.0.CO;2-U.
Ottonello L, Cutolo M, Frumento G, Arduino N, Bertolotto M, Mancini M, Sottofattori E, Dallegri F: Synovial fluid from patients with rheumatoid arthritis inhibits neutrophil apoptosis: role of adenosine and proinflammatory cytokines. Rheumatology (Oxford). 2002, 41: 1249-1260. 10.1093/rheumatology/41.11.1249.
Buckley CD, Pilling D, Lord JM, Akbar AN, Scheel-Toellner D, Salmon M: Fibroblasts regulate the switch from acute resolving to chronic persistent inflammation. Trends Immunol. 2001, 22: 199-204. 10.1016/S1471-4906(01)01863-4.
Raza K, Falciani F, Curnow SJ, Ross EJ, Lee CY, Akbar AN, Lord JM, Gordon C, Buckley CD, Salmon M: Early rheumatoid arthritis is characterized by a distinct and transient synovial fluid cytokine profile of T cell and stromal cell origin. Arthritis Res Ther. 2005, 7: R784-R795. 10.1186/ar1733.
Raza K, Lee CY, Pilling D, Heaton S, Situnayake RD, Carruthers DM, Buckley CD, Gordon C, Salmon M: Ultrasound guidance allows accurate needle placement and aspiration from small joints in patients with early inflammatory arthritis. Rheumatology (Oxford). 2003, 42: 976-979. 10.1093/rheumatology/keg269.
Arnett FC, Edworthy SM, Bloch DA, McShane DJ, Fries JF, Cooper NS, Healey LA, Kaplan SR, Liang MH, Luthra HS, et al: The American Rheumatism Association 1987 revised criteria for the classification of rheumatoid arthritis. Arthritis Rheum. 1988, 31: 315-324.
Herman S, Zurgil N, Deutsch M: Low dose methotrexate induces apoptosis with reactive oxygen species involvement in T lymphocytic cell lines to a greater extent than in monocytic lines. Inflamm Res. 2005, 54: 273-280. 10.1007/s00011-005-1355-8.
Liptay S, Fulda S, Schanbacher M, Bourteele S, Ferri KF, Kroemer G, Adler G, Debatin KM, Schmid RM: Molecular mechanisms of sulfasalazine-induced T-cell apoptosis. Br J Pharmacol. 2002, 137: 608-620. 10.1038/sj.bjp.0704870.
Nanki T, Hayashida K, El Gabalawy HS, Suson S, Shi K, Girschick HJ, Yavuz S, Lipsky PE: Stromal cell-derived factor-1-CXC chemokine receptor 4 interactions play a central role in CD4+ T cell accumulation in rheumatoid arthritis synovium. J Immunol. 2000, 165: 6590-6598.
Suzuki Y, Rahman M, Mitsuya H: Diverse transcriptionalresponse of CD4+ T cells to stromal cell-derived factor (SDF)-1:cell survival promotion and priming effects of SDF-1 on CD4+ T cells. J Immunol. 2001, 167: 3064-3073.
Atreya R, Mudter J, Finotto S, Mullberg J, Jostock T, Wirtz S, Schutz M, Bartsch B, Holtmann M, Becker C, et al: Blockade of interleukin 6 trans signaling suppresses T-cell resistance against apoptosis in chronic intestinal inflammation: evidence in crohn disease and experimental colitis in vivo. Nat Med. 2000, 6: 583-588. 10.1038/75068.
Wang K, Scheel-Toellner D, Wong SH, Craddock R, Caamano J, Akbar AN, Salmon M, Lord JM: Inhibition of neutrophil apoptosis by type 1 IFN depends on cross-talk between phosphoinositol 3-kinase, protein kinase C-delta and NF-kappaB signalling pathways. J Immunol. 2003, 171: 1035-1041.
Orteu CH, Poulter LW, Rustin MH, Sabin CA, Salmon M, Akbar AN: The role of apoptosis in the resolution of T cell-mediated cutaneous inflammation. J Immunol. 1998, 161: 1619-1629.
Fulop T, Fouquet C, Allaire P, Perrin N, Lacombe G, Stankova J, Rola-Pleszczynski M, Gagne D, Wagner JR, Khalil A, et al: Changes in apoptosis of human polymorphonuclear granulocytes with aging. Mech Ageing Dev. 1997, 96: 15-34. 10.1016/S0047-6374(96)01881-7.
Tortorella C, Piazzolla G, Spaccavento F, Pece S, Jirillo E, Antonaci S: Spontaneous and Fas-induced apoptotic cell death in aged neutrophils. J Clin Immunol. 1998, 18: 321-329. 10.1023/A:1023286831246.
Schindowski K, Leutner S, Muller WE, Eckert A: Age-related changes of apoptotic cell death in human lymphocytes. Neurobiol Aging. 2000, 21: 661-670. 10.1016/S0197-4580(00)00171-8.
Phelouzat MA, Arbogast A, Laforge T, Quadri RA, Proust JJ: Excessive apoptosis of mature T lymphocytes is a characteristic feature of human immune senescence. Mech Ageing Dev. 1996, 88: 25-38. 10.1016/0047-6374(96)01714-9.
This work was supported by the Arthritis Research Campaign (ARC).
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
KR participated in the design of the study, recruited and followed-up the early arthritis patients, analyzed and interpreted the data, and drafted the manuscript. DST participated in the design of the study and the writing of the manuscript. CYL participated in assessing patients and in performing ultrasound-guided joint aspirations. DP participated in the design of the study and the writing of the manuscript. SJC, VT and FF contributed to the analysis and interpretation of the data. KK participated in assessing patients with early synovitis. JML participated in the design of the study and interpretation of data. CG participated in the design of the study and interpretation of data. CB participated in the design of the study and interpretation of data. MS participated in the design of the study and interpretation of data, and was involved in drafting the manuscript. All authors have read and approved the final manuscript.
About this article
Cite this article
Raza, K., Scheel-Toellner, D., Lee, C. et al. Synovial fluid leukocyte apoptosis is inhibited in patients with very early rheumatoid arthritis. Arthritis Res Ther 8, R120 (2006) doi:10.1186/ar2009
- Rheumatoid Arthritis
- Rheumatoid Arthritis Patient
- Synovial Fluid
- Inflammatory Arthritis